What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

Status
Not open for further replies.
The only reason I'd ever buy naming rights would be to keep them out of the hands of some scumbucket corporation or donor who wanted to slap his own name on it.

Someday Lynah will fall apart. And Cornell in their infinite idiocy will build some hideous series of concentric complexes like a factory school to house the successor. When the worlds award me $1T for my combination of good sense and great looks, I'll glady cough up a couple billion to ensure the names: Laing Kennedy Athletic Complex; Ken Dryden Hockey Center; James Lynah Rink.

Was Lynah a goalie, too?
 
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

I'm not referencing Trump's remarks here, but yours. In the very good Vice Documentary that Slap posted this morning, one of the local activists references Monticello and what I took to mean Jefferson as "The Master sitting on top of Monticello... He looks down on us" (It is right here.)

Charlottesville is of course, the home of the University of Virginia, designed by Jefferson and Monticello sits on a hill nearby. Obviously Jefferson was a slave owner. My question is, if it comes to it, how is that best handled?

Winners vs. losers.

On another board, someone asked if Washington could be considered a traitor. In the eyes of the British, of course he was. Duh. And since he won, he's a hero of ours.

Your info about Jefferson is a good example that our Founding Fathers are not without fault. Which is a way to point out that what they wrote is up to real debate, but that's a different thread.

Thomas Jefferson did pen this
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.

Given all of his faults, we've been trying for that to come true ever since it went public. AND we are still working on it.

We had a Civil War about it. People have gone back and claimed of many other reasons, but they all come back to the economics of the south- to make a lot of money, they needed slavery to pay for it. There's no way around it.

Because of that Civil war, Robert E Lee and Stonewall Jackson were both traitors to the United States of America, they are both losers, too. They were part of the US army, and then decided to take arms against that country- the definition of traitors, AND they lost that war- so they are losers, too. How we go about celebrating traitor losers like that is beyond me. Sure, some markers to define the history of what happened- we should not forget that at all. But to put them on a pedestal for being a traitor loser? What's up with that?

Put it in the context of history when the statues were mostly put up, as well as the confederate flags being parts of states- you can easily see that it's a reaction for the people they oppressed getting any type of advantage.

Back the original point- Jackson and Lee were losers and traitors, Washington and Jefferson were revolutionary winners. It's pretty simple.
 
Charlottesville is of course, the home of the University of Virginia, designed by Jefferson and Monticello sits on a hill nearby. Obviously Jefferson was a slave owner. My question is, if it comes to it, how is that best handled?

With respect, remeberance, and somber tones. Auschwitz still stand even though it is a deep, dark spot in history. Other similar dark marks in history are preserved the same in an effort to teach the future.

So treat Jefferson's home with care.


Unlike these statues the alt-right treat like Six Flags Over Confederacy.
 
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

While Washington and Jefferson both did own slaves, which will be a stain on them, they both helped found the country and did not take up arms against it. Neither of the latter is true about Lee or Jackson, so we're left with only the former. Maybe that's a dry way of looking at it, but it's hard to overlook those points when considering who deserves a statue. (I mean, in terms of military genius, Jackson was amazing; but that means I will read about it in history books, which still exist and will continue to.)
 
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

The terrorists are getting out of hand, calm down people
edit: I guess this guy is a liberal along the lines of the guy that shot up a baseball game. Still, it's all a symptom of Trump's America
 
I'm not referencing Trump's remarks here, but yours. In the very good Vice Documentary that Slap posted this morning, one of the local activists references Monticello and what I took to mean Jefferson as "The Master sitting on top of Monticello... He looks down on us" (It is right here.)

Charlottesville is of course, the home of the University of Virginia, designed by Jefferson and Monticello sits on a hill nearby. Obviously Jefferson was a slave owner. My question is, if it comes to it, how is that best handled?

I dunno... that is a very good question.
 
I dunno... that is a very good question.

IIRC 30 some odd signers of the Declaration of Independence were slave owners.

IIRC at the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg, the survivors marched across the field and shook hands with each other.

What about the Nazis?

We read the writings of Nazi generals and admirals, some who served in the new West German armed forces. They served an evil government, yet we didn't shoot/hang them all. Some were respected lecturers after the war in this country.

Our German scientists were better than Russia's German scientists and we got to the moon first.

We hate the Nazis but like the Germans? Why can't we decry the Rebellion and honor the participants?
 
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

Why can't we decry the Rebellion and honor the participants?

I don't care much for "whitewashing history" and I'm very leery of mob justice (a tiny group of people destroying common property). And I HATE identity politics, people basing all their self-worth, votes, positions, opinions, etc on their appearance/nationality/lifestyle in opposition to other groups of people who are lighter or darker or straighter or whatever. People are individuals.
But there are a lot of people who do have strong opinions about their own neighborhoods, and I fully respect that. If there are enough of them to vote in an orderly local referendum for the controlled removal of these statues, I don't mind it a bit. I'd have to be insane to drive to some other state with my gun and confederate flag to protest something that's so clearly not my business. If I do, hopefully the people that live there will punch me in the face and then kick me after I'm down until I either leave or wake up. It's just disgusting.
Also: Robert E Lee was not some unusually evil demon like Hitler, he was quite accomplished and widely admired throughout the country at the time of the war. He went to war in defense of his home state in spite of his loyalties to the U.S., he was more or less schizophrenic only in a way typical of Americans of the time in his ideals. All the rage against him is a fairly recent construct.
Still, not my neighborhood so no skin off my nose if it's destroyed.
 
Last edited:
IIRC 30 some odd signers of the Declaration of Independence were slave owners.

IIRC at the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg, the survivors marched across the field and shook hands with each other.

What about the Nazis?

We read the writings of Nazi generals and admirals, some who served in the new West German armed forces. They served an evil government, yet we didn't shoot/hang them all. Some were respected lecturers after the war in this country.

Our German scientists were better than Russia's German scientists and we got to the moon first.

We hate the Nazis but like the Germans? Why can't we decry the Rebellion and honor the participants?

Where are the 1500 monuments to the British on US soil?
 
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

Since some of you continue to quote flagdummy- re- the news.

I'd like to point out flaggy seemed to be posting sporadically at best in these threads of late and most were doing a good job of not "quoting" him. Today the quotes were coming fast and furious and so were the posts. Proof positive that YOU MUST NOT FEED THE TROLLS!
 
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

...so ESPN fantasy football introduced a fun new spin on their draft format today where a white auctioneer holds up a picture of a black dude in front of a room full of fat white dudes and "sells" him to the highest bidder. :eek:
 
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

The terrorists are getting out of hand, calm down people
edit: I guess this guy is a liberal along the lines of the guy that shot up a baseball game. Still, it's all a symptom of Trump's America

Here's the local news story that makes it clear this went waaaay beyond mere politics, as much as Gateway Pundit (lol) wants you to think it was because he was a Trump hater. The guy was a lunatic and an arsehole.
 
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

Here's the local news story that makes it clear this went waaaay beyond mere politics, as much as Gateway Pundit (lol) wants you to think it was because he was a Trump hater. The guy was a lunatic and an arsehole.
Yeah, that's the story I thought I was sending, they didn't even mention the political activism so I was under the assumption he was a Trumper. Somehow I linked a tab that played up the guy's politics.
Deranged lone wolf, like the baseball shooter and the cop killers.
 
IIRC 30 some odd signers of the Declaration of Independence were slave owners.

IIRC at the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg, the survivors marched across the field and shook hands with each other.

What about the Nazis?

We read the writings of Nazi generals and admirals, some who served in the new West German armed forces. They served an evil government, yet we didn't shoot/hang them all. Some were respected lecturers after the war in this country.

Our German scientists were better than Russia's German scientists and we got to the moon first.

We hate the Nazis but like the Germans? Why can't we decry the Rebellion and honor the participants?

Nice try...the Germans denounced the Nazis hell made the flag illegal. The South still embraces the Confederacy. Until they do we shouldnt embrace them. The South Shall Not Rise Again.

Care to try again without sounding completely lost?
 
Last edited:
Re: POTUS 45.16 - If Never Forgotten, One Would ALWAYS Remember Something.

Nice try...the Germans denounced the Nazis he'll made the flag illegal. The South still embraces the Confederacy.

Care to try again without sounding completely lost?

One weird wrinkle to the Stars And Bars (as we know current flag): to many, it is NOT a symbol of slavery/Confederacy. It's simply a symbol of southern life: laid back, rural, aw shucks farmer wisdom life. Think: Lynyrd Skynyrd, Dukes Of Hazzard. I don't know of anyone who thinks of the Nazi flag that way.

Now, I'm not saying it's right or wrong, it's just a very odd wrinkle with the newer generations of southern folk.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top