Re: POTUS 45.09: How do I hate thee? Let me count the posts.
Not defending the USSR in anyway, but I still think you are confusing things.
When the Russian revolution began, EVERYTHING was owned by royalty of some type. All of it. And everyone else was treated like crap.
Where people died was when Communism in one person's view was different than someone else- and the thug won. And won over anyone who didn't agree. That's not communism speaking, that's thuggery.
Given how the world was going, England was lucky to have a Parliament that they elected- as they could have easily fallen into the same spot at the Russians had they not- people died in WWI due to the "Lords" being the only ones that could be officers, and most were terrible at doing it, and much of the population was cheap labor. Just like in Russia.
The thuggery is one MORE reason that so many people are against don- he's a two bit thug. And is using the office as his battering ram.
Hitler came to power in an elected government system, too. Left unchecked, we saw what happened there.
The reasons why communism doesn't work isn't because of thuggery and dictatorships. It's because people just can't work that way.
But they are pretty inseparable. One leads to the other. And as an example, where does Marx say the bourgeoisie gives up their property voluntarily for the good of the state? He doesn't, because they won't. Which means the proletariat must seize their property by force. And as people are generally inclined to protect their homes and property, you're probably gonna have to kill or imprison them to take their stuff. Which as we've seen several times, is exactly the form this particular ideology takes. Just ask 65 million Chinese or 20 million Russians. (You can't. They're dead.)
And even after that initial murdering is done, it continues, because Communism as some happy, "everybody is equal - no one is above anyone else" does not exist because for one, people are not wired that way and someone will always take power unchecked. Pretending the ideology when put into practice leads to something else that is good, is just that -- pretend.
Not defending the USSR in anyway, but I still think you are confusing things.
When the Russian revolution began, EVERYTHING was owned by royalty of some type. All of it. And everyone else was treated like crap.
Where people died was when Communism in one person's view was different than someone else- and the thug won. And won over anyone who didn't agree. That's not communism speaking, that's thuggery.
Given how the world was going, England was lucky to have a Parliament that they elected- as they could have easily fallen into the same spot at the Russians had they not- people died in WWI due to the "Lords" being the only ones that could be officers, and most were terrible at doing it, and much of the population was cheap labor. Just like in Russia.
The thuggery is one MORE reason that so many people are against don- he's a two bit thug. And is using the office as his battering ram.
Hitler came to power in an elected government system, too. Left unchecked, we saw what happened there.
The reasons why communism doesn't work isn't because of thuggery and dictatorships. It's because people just can't work that way.