Re: Nice Planet 17: I Need a Cold ****ty Beer to Deal with You ***holes
It was never true, because no country is perfect. But it was taught. It was believed, certainly by large segments of the populace. And that teaching and that belief helped make it a better place than it otherwise would have been because there was that ideal to try to live up to.
It didn't create a perfect country for women, who were second class citizens for much of the country's history. It didn't create a perfect country for minorities who felt the harm of discrimination. But it made the country a heck of a lot better than it might otherwise have been, and it made a country that good people around the world wanted to migrate to, which in turn made the country better.
Yes, american exceptionalism has always been part myth, but I don't think the solution is to teach the opposite. Teaching that we are a country filled with discriminating nazi thugs has the same effect, just in the opposite direction. As a country we have tended to live down to that "ideal" as well.
We have never led.
"We're juuuuuuuuust anotherrrrrrrrrrr country." The stuff we learned in school about America as a city on the hill was propaganda. We were better than a lot of awful places, and much richer, so people came here. People still come here from Honduras and Vietnam and Iraq. But we were never "great." That was just empty words.
Our job is to make it better than it was. For most people (non-whites, women, non-Christians) America has always sucked. Our job is to make it not suck. For the first time.
Whenever we pass a civil rights law or make the powerful stop abusing the powerless we are breaking new ground. We aren't restoring America; we're changing it from the lie it always was to the truth we always wanted.
It was never true, because no country is perfect. But it was taught. It was believed, certainly by large segments of the populace. And that teaching and that belief helped make it a better place than it otherwise would have been because there was that ideal to try to live up to.
It didn't create a perfect country for women, who were second class citizens for much of the country's history. It didn't create a perfect country for minorities who felt the harm of discrimination. But it made the country a heck of a lot better than it might otherwise have been, and it made a country that good people around the world wanted to migrate to, which in turn made the country better.
Yes, american exceptionalism has always been part myth, but I don't think the solution is to teach the opposite. Teaching that we are a country filled with discriminating nazi thugs has the same effect, just in the opposite direction. As a country we have tended to live down to that "ideal" as well.