What's new
By:
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

NFL 2022-23: How About A Lions vs. Jaguars Super Bowl?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Spartanforlife4 said:
Those fines are locked in by the CBA. I don’t know why Walker didn’t get fined for the Buffalo ejection, but 13k was the maximum for a first offense for an unsportsmanlike fine. Trainers don’t fall under contact with an official which would’ve deemed a much higher penalty.

Williams’ was his second fine of the year for celebrating. So he got the second offense level of 18k.

As for Reed, on review they may not have deemed him defenseless. As bad as it looks I think that play is technically legal if he was still considered a runner.
Click to expand...

So yea, it was his second ejection for pushing a non player. So that should have been worse.

Why did Williams get fined for that? It is bad to celebrate against the packers? Pretty weak.

And I don't think a direct forearm to the head is legal at all. Runner or not- that was direct hit to the head, and it was clearly intended to do that to his head instead of his body. But now players at least know you can attempt to knock out your opponent via a head shot and not get penalized.

That's a pretty bad look for the players and NFL is a simple dance like that- is deemed so offensive that it gets penalized more than a guy who forearms a head plus a player who pushes a non player twice in a season.
 
In other news, formerly fired Colts coach Frank Reich gets hired by the Carolina Panthers. The Panthers overlooked the interim coach Steve Wilks who took managed to get the team to finish 6-6 for an overall record of 7-10. Mind you, they ended up very much in contention for the division championship. Wilks is an African American, so the Panthers and the NFL again look bad for a bad looking hire over a good looking black coach.

As much as I appreciate Saturday with his analysis- if he gets the Colts job.....
 
MichVandal said:
So yea, it was his second ejection for pushing a non player. So that should have been worse.

Why did Williams get fined for that? It is bad to celebrate against the packers? Pretty weak.

And I don't think a direct forearm to the head is legal at all. Runner or not- that was direct hit to the head, and it was clearly intended to do that to his head instead of his body. But now players at least know you can attempt to knock out your opponent via a head shot and not get penalized.

That's a pretty bad look for the players and NFL is a simple dance like that- is deemed so offensive that it gets penalized more than a guy who forearms a head plus a player who pushes a non player twice in a season.
Click to expand...

He got fined for a similar celebration against the Vikings. I think the NFL is literally enforcing the rule from the Key and Peele skit on hip thrusts.

For Reed, if the NFL rule is like the college rule (they don’t have targeting, but they’ve changed their rules to more or less match it minus the ejection), the runner is basically fair game unless you hit him with your helmet. If they’re the same/similar then really all you could call is a flagrant act and eject on that play if they’re calling him a runner. Now if he’s defenseless (which great argument to be made that he is) then it should’ve been a foul.

Here’s the fine table. I had no idea they fined players for facemask penalties.

https://operations.nfl.com/inside-football-ops/rules-enforcement/accountability-fines-appeals/

Although looking here, they must only fine for blatant acts, because there aren’t many face masks showing up.

https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/fines-suspensions/2022/
 
Spartanforlife4 said:
He got fined for a similar celebration against the Vikings. I think the NFL is literally enforcing the rule from the Key and Peele skit on hip thrusts.

For Reed, if the NFL rule is like the college rule (they don’t have targeting, but they’ve changed their rules to more or less match it minus the ejection), the runner is basically fair game unless you hit him with your helmet. If they’re the same/similar then really all you could call is a flagrant act and eject on that play if they’re calling him a runner. Now if he’s defenseless (which great argument to be made that he is) then it should’ve been a foul.

Here’s the fine table. I had no idea they fined players for facemask penalties.

https://operations.nfl.com/inside-football-ops/rules-enforcement/accountability-fines-appeals/

Although looking here, they must only fine for blatant acts, because there aren’t many face masks showing up.

https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/fines-suspensions/2022/
Click to expand...

The dance looks as much like a Billy Johnson celebration from the 70's as anything else.

Again, the look of that being so bad it gets fined vs. the combination of the other two is pretty weak. Being potentially offensive is worse than shoving a non player and using your forearm as a potential weapon. This just a week after a player almost died on the field- so you would think that trying to cause harm is looked down upon and celebrating a good thing is not harmful.
 
MichVandal said:
In other news, formerly fired Colts coach Frank Reich gets hired by the Carolina Panthers. The Panthers overlooked the interim coach Steve Wilks who took managed to get the team to finish 6-6 for an overall record of 7-10. Mind you, they ended up very much in contention for the division championship. Wilks is an African American, so the Panthers and the NFL again look bad for a bad looking hire over a good looking black coach.

As much as I appreciate Saturday with his analysis- if he gets the Colts job.....
Click to expand...

Irsay wants to but the front office doesn't, so Saturday will be announced soon.
 
MichVandal said:
In other news, formerly fired Colts coach Frank Reich gets hired by the Carolina Panthers. The Panthers overlooked the interim coach Steve Wilks who took managed to get the team to finish 6-6 for an overall record of 7-10. Mind you, they ended up very much in contention for the division championship. Wilks is an African American, so the Panthers and the NFL again look bad for a bad looking hire over a good looking black coach.

As much as I appreciate Saturday with his analysis- if he gets the Colts job.....
Click to expand...

All the more impressive that Wilks did most of that *after* they traded McCaffrey.
 
This is an aesthetically pleasing clash of uniforms between two teams I frequently forget exist.

Pro sports needs more green. When Portland eventually gets baseball and hockey in 2050 (when it has 2M people), I hope we will bring a city-wide green color scheme.
 
Last edited:
Shanahan needs to come up with a shorter menu to let Johnson run the offense. It’s still close- only 7-0 due to a missed drop.
 
Now we have a game. And both teams benefited from a miss call- the QB can’t tap his foot when someone is in motion and SF scored on that.
 
Well, maybe not. SF’s D is gifting first downs to Philly. Giving them the opportunity for 2 TDs that they could have stopped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top