Re: MLB 2019 and Beyond: Something Something Three True Outcomes....
I’m a little surprised Jeter got that high of %. I’m not necessarily big on the stupid games some writers play, I’m just surprised there wasn’t the same games played. I get it, he’s “YEA! JEETS!” but he was surrounded by an incredible cast throughout his career. Which is fine, a lot of people have been.
But it’s funny that his gray numbers are literally average for a HOFer.
https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/j/jeterde01.shtml#all_hof_other
Second all time offensive WAR, but fourth worst defensive WAR (-8.3) for a SS top JAWS SS. Heh, now I’m digging into it. No one below a +5.5 dWAR has ever been elected as SS. Just to show you how important that position usually is defensively.*. For middle infield, only Biggio (-2.9), and Carew (-1.7) have ever gotten in under 0. Edgar Martinez (-9, 2/3 of his games at DH), Molitor (-6.9, 1/2 at DH) got in. Eight 1B were worse and got in. 7 LF, 2 CF (mantle and Cobb), 11 RF. Zero C ever. 12 IF, 32 OF have ever been elected with sub-zero dWAR.
That said, he almost certainly belongs given his longevity and overall milestone accumulation. It’s just interesting the dynamics of elections.
*i still can’t believe they didn’t move his *** to 3B or some other position where he couldn’t do as much damage. Then again, when you surround yourself with juiced up howitzers who can’t play defense either...