Rebounds ....... Food for thought.........
Many how have not played goal do not understand rebounds.
#1. Goalies sometimes attempt to kick a big rebound out versus having it hand close to their crease. I agree
#2. There are several different manufacturers of goalie pads. Some have more ribs, based on padding and sticking which will kick rebounds to places unknown and unanticipated. After 8 months of practice and games goalies (better ones anyway) know their pads and limit their "unknown and unantcipated" rebounds
#3. New pads create bigger rebounds and so it depends where the lifespan of the pads are at. Maybe
#4. Not all puck are mad the same and if you have a small indent or chip the puck will come off the pads differently than normal. That's a theory I have never heard before...not a likely one though
#5. Soft (old) pads give soft rebounds but are sloppy on the goalie and in fact create a shrunken goalie, yes better rebound control, but smaller goalie. Reiteration of #3
Overall note is that goaltending is a game of micro inches (not inches).