Hey Fish, you might want to pay attention to what’s going outside your own team’s conference if you intend to discuss this kind of stuff. Geneseo and Potsdam each received a postseason ban in 2010. In other words, the exact same punishment received by Neumann. It was announced in January of that season, and a few weeks later it was determined that Morrisville became eligible that season, which was the only reason the last-placed team (Cortland, I believe?) didn’t sneak into the playoffs.
Now, the Public schools got punished because ~30% of the recipients of a grant were athletes, while only ~15% of all students are athletes. For Neumann, it was something like 98% compared to 11%. Those numbers could lead one to conclude intentional circumvention of the rules. How they kept the 2009 National Championship (won with the grant in place) baffles me to this day.