WisconsinWildcard
The plural of anecdote is not data
Re: Dr. Clayton Forrester's Science Roundup
Bohannon is doing great work exposing some of the flaws of the peer review process and the perils of open access journals. I generally support the open access movement but I think it needs to be done carefully and his work goes a long way. The nutrition/food/diet research community was quite the low hanging fruit as anyone familiar with the level of accepted evidence in many of those circles is far too low. There are a few groups out there doing excellent work but the vast majority is very poorly controlled noise that the media loves to run with and many dubious conclusions are based upon.
I have heard a few criticisms of Bohannon within the scientific community but as a whole, I think most approve of what he is doing and believe it will have a positive effect on the peer review process.
This guy released a "report on a study" that combinging 1.5oz of chocolate to a low-card diet caused dieters to lose weight 10% faster than a low-card diet without chocolate. He did it as a commentary on how science and health news reports are filtered out to the public and why we have to beware of what we're reading.
Bohannon is doing great work exposing some of the flaws of the peer review process and the perils of open access journals. I generally support the open access movement but I think it needs to be done carefully and his work goes a long way. The nutrition/food/diet research community was quite the low hanging fruit as anyone familiar with the level of accepted evidence in many of those circles is far too low. There are a few groups out there doing excellent work but the vast majority is very poorly controlled noise that the media loves to run with and many dubious conclusions are based upon.
I have heard a few criticisms of Bohannon within the scientific community but as a whole, I think most approve of what he is doing and believe it will have a positive effect on the peer review process.