Chuck Murray
WIS & Effingwoods Hockey Almanac
IMO, this is comparing apples and oranges. UConn hockey was not competitive in Atlantic Hockey, or DIII for that matter. There's a difference between being in the dregs of Hockey East and being in the dregs of competitive college hockey. The UConn program did not enter D1 until 1998, many years after all of the examples you mentioned. As a long-time fan, I can say that this year was the best year UConn Hockey has ever experienced, and the last few years have been very exciting for us older supporters of the program. UConn has been very competitive for the last few years and it's been great.
All of your examples are about programs with serious hockey history. I remember Billy Riley running a successful program at Lowell in the 80's, UNH has been a mainstay of New England college hockey for a long time, and of course NU. All of these schools you compare UConn to have very strong college hockey history. How are they comparable to UConn? I'm not following your logic.
Either way, I'm not here to debate, IMO (as a supporter), I am over the moon with the success and momentum of UConn Hockey! I hope Coach Cav stays, but I also understand it's the yin and yang of building a program.
* UNH was competitively dismal throughout the '80's, before Umile took over
* UMass Lowell was rarely a factor in D-1 HEA for many years prior to Bazin
* Northeastern was mediocre for generations prior to Madigan
BUT the most apt comparison of the bunch is this one ...
* UMass WAS the dregs of HEA before the arrival of Carvel. He's accomplished many times more than Luce has at UConn, and done it in significantly less time. This example blows away the "look where we came from, and where we are now" argument for Luce/UConn.
Your program had its best year in its history this season. Your coach has enjoyed the benefit of a ton of patience, lots more than many other coaches with similar records have enjoyed before losing their jobs. If that's enough to convince BC he's the man to take over for York, I'll tell you right here and now, UConn fans will find out fairly quickly from the next guy that Luce wasn't that great. And BC fans will have confirmed for them what they already know, which is that York was a once-in-a-lifetime coach for their program, and replacing him is not going to be an easy task. Just as replacing Coach Parker down at the other end of Comm Ave. has proven to be a much more difficult task than many at BU ever imagined it might be ...