Re: Boston University Offseason Thread 2: Moving Forward by Booting Forwards
Sorry in advance, long post:
I think the battle for the 5th and 6th defensive spots could be an interesting one to watch. Rosen has a fair amount of upside, and I think a full year working with Boyle could be good for him. I'm interested to see if Noonan can handle the Division I college game our of the gates, and I think we're all eager just to see Ruikka actually put on a jersey.
To me the D breaks into 3 levels:
Automatic starters: 5, 7, 21, and Clendening (should he come, which is anything but automatic)
Competing for playing time: 4, 8, Noonan (I think odds are 8 will be the lone man out more often simply because his offensive style is overly abundant in the top 4)
Injury Relief: MacGregor (I'm always open to being proven wrong)
On defense, Ken's top four seems like pretty much a lock. My gut says Noonan and Ruikka get the bulk of playing time as the third pairing. We'll see. Ruikka getting a lot of playing time wouldn't make a bad story either...
I actually break up the top 4 because I don't see two of the remaining 4 being capable of playing D1 quality defense together:
5-7
Clendening- Noonan/4
Noonan/4-21
or
5-Noonan/4
Clendening-7
Noonan/4-21
A question for those closer to the situation than I; If Andy Glass becomes a career "healthy scratch" guy, will that be a big surprise compared to the expectations when he was recruited?
In the draft pick sense he would be a large bust, however in terms of a scholarship sense, it would put him in a similar situation as Smolinsky.
You could definitely argue that Coyle and Nieto are the most purely talented forwards on the team.
Can you argue that they are not in the top 5? Based on scouting evaluations both are more complete players than Bonino was entering BU, with Nieto probably being closer to Wilson than Bonino. Doesn't mean they will turn out the same way though.
The thing about a freshman line this year is that none of the freshman forwards are natural centers, and none of them played center much this past season.
12 wasn't a true center and Coyle is listed as a RW/C. I think there is a distinct possibility of it happening.
For lines no matter how I slice it I end up with 3 lines that are all solid 2nd line quality. A freshman needs to burst onto the scene or some returnees needs to improve significantly if the team is to have a true first line, but our 3rd line always seems impressive (especially in the 2nd scenario).
My stab:
Connolly Trivino Chiasson
Pereira Megan Nieto
Glass Gaudet Coyle
Gill Santana Gilroy
or with a frosh line:
Connolly Trivino Chiasson
Gill Coyle Nieto
Pereira Megan Gaudet
Glass Santana Gilroy
Should Cisse come Gilroy is the odd man out, but in the first line scenario Cisse would push Glass to 4th line who would then push Gilroy off the 4th line.