Federal League
I like hockey.
Re: Boston University 2010-11 part II - The Hunt For Red November
Is the 118 experience really all that different, though? Serious question. Obviously I'm not down there any more, so I don't know the exact dynamics of what's going on now. But what you're describing really doesn't sound all that different from what the Dog Pound was like the two years I was in it. I remember frequently thinking it was unorganized. I remember even after two years, I didn't know who "the leader" was. I knew there were a few fans who were louder than most that I could've guessed were the leaders (more on this being plural in a minute), but if someone came up to me two years ago and asked me who the leader was, I wouldn't have known. Also, I remember thinking there was plenty of apathy even then. I almost always had at least a handful of people within a few seats of me who would barely make a peep all game.
But back to the leader. Why does there have to be a leader, singular? I think the biggest thing 118 had going for it when I was there was that there were about 10 people who were very vocal and would start chants at any time. If 118 is relying on just one person to start chants now, then that's a whole separate issue. Again, I don't want to make excuses for this one person because I'm sure he could be better at what he does, but it seems to me that it would be better for everyone if he had some help. Maybe he needs to do a better job of recruiting help. Like I said, I have no idea what the dynamics are. But if 118's relying on one person, then I think that's the root of the problem right there.
BTW, that was a column, not an editorial. An editorial is written anonymously by the paper's editorial board. /Journalistic correctness
It sounds to me that instead of confronting the 118 issue, we are just pumping up 108 to compensate. it is great that 108 has become such a big presense at games and it has really enhanced the atmosphere. trust me, there are few things i love more than a "goalie-sieve" call and response. that doesnt change the fact that the experience in 118 is not what it was a few years ago. i have had people come up to me on multiple occassions and tell me this. like tommynoble, ive had people that i do not know ask me who the leader is. perhaps some of us were spoiled by very strong and vocal leaders. i think that there are always improvements that can be made and this editorial gives the student section a great opportunity to try and work something new in or revamp some of the older traditions that have kind of weeded their way out.
that was a pretty poorly written editorial, i agree. And his example of the Beanpot was just awful. But the overall experience isnt what it was last year or the year before. So the only thing to do is take this chance to make some improvements. The team is making adjustments and has improved their game quite a bit in the last few weeks, so the student section can probably do the same.
Is the 118 experience really all that different, though? Serious question. Obviously I'm not down there any more, so I don't know the exact dynamics of what's going on now. But what you're describing really doesn't sound all that different from what the Dog Pound was like the two years I was in it. I remember frequently thinking it was unorganized. I remember even after two years, I didn't know who "the leader" was. I knew there were a few fans who were louder than most that I could've guessed were the leaders (more on this being plural in a minute), but if someone came up to me two years ago and asked me who the leader was, I wouldn't have known. Also, I remember thinking there was plenty of apathy even then. I almost always had at least a handful of people within a few seats of me who would barely make a peep all game.
But back to the leader. Why does there have to be a leader, singular? I think the biggest thing 118 had going for it when I was there was that there were about 10 people who were very vocal and would start chants at any time. If 118 is relying on just one person to start chants now, then that's a whole separate issue. Again, I don't want to make excuses for this one person because I'm sure he could be better at what he does, but it seems to me that it would be better for everyone if he had some help. Maybe he needs to do a better job of recruiting help. Like I said, I have no idea what the dynamics are. But if 118's relying on one person, then I think that's the root of the problem right there.
BTW, that was a column, not an editorial. An editorial is written anonymously by the paper's editorial board. /Journalistic correctness