What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

2020 Democratic Challengers IV: Culling the Herd

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you're right about that.

There was a Nebraska state senator the other day who went off on Ttump for being a white supremacist. For his clarity, he was kicked out of the GOP, then... what got to me... he was absolutely savaged on Twitter for switching sides, by liberal Democrats (“4 years too late, azzhole” etc) The dude has nowhere to go, and any incentive his colleagues might have had to join him is gone. The vitriol is way out of hand. Repentance needs to be met with forgiveness.
 
Four years too late? They forgot a zero.

I was unclear. The accusation by fools was that if he supported Ttump at the start of his campaign, he should stand by Ttump forever or be branded a traitor. (Whereas it seems obvious to me that such awakenings ought to be encouraged and rewarded)
 
But then you have this (from The Hill, which I think we can all agree is a solid source):
https://thehill.com/homenews/house/...alized-communities-have-no-choice-but-to-riot

Not exactly trying to bridge the gap here, are we? :(
So people of Flint who are being poisoned with lead tainted water needs to just shut up and drink the water? Mothers of kids shot in Chicago should just shut up and let the blood paint the streets? Poor rural Americans who do not have access to healthcare should just sit in their homes and die? Palestinians should just welcome Israel bulldozers to demolish their land and commit self genocide? Miss Thundercat should be told to use the bathroom at her house because she's not welcome to use public restrooms?

Your both-sidesism is quite the elephant in the room.
Yep.
 
Re: 2020 Democratic Challengers IV: Culling the Herd

There was a Nebraska state senator the other day who went off on Ttump for being a white supremacist. For his clarity, he was kicked out of the GOP, then... what got to me... he was absolutely savaged on Twitter for switching sides, by liberal Democrats (“4 years too late, azzhole” etc) The dude has nowhere to go, and any incentive his colleagues might have had to join him is gone. The vitriol is way out of hand. Repentance needs to be met with forgiveness.

We should welcome anybody who leaves the GOP. People become Republicans for all sorts of reasons. Bad parenting. Lack of education. Falling in with the wrong crowd. A crippling embarrassment during toilet training.

For voters, welcome them unconditionally -- every saved R counts as a 2-vote swing! For Members, welcome them, tell them how to vote, and when they backslide have a better nominee in our back pocket.

No soul is beyond help. Hate the sin, love the sinner.
 
Re: 2020 Democratic Challengers IV: Culling the Herd

So they should riot?

Riot:
take part in a violent public disturbance.
"students rioted in Paris"
synonyms: rampage, go on the rampage, run riot, take to the streets, fight in the streets, start a fight, raise an uproar, cause an affray, run/go wild, run amok, go berserk, fight, brawl, scuffle; informalraise hell
"the miners rioted and attacked the local Party HQ"

How is that any different than people criticizing the righties for the same sort of language?
 
Re: 2020 Democratic Challengers IV: Culling the Herd

But even when minorities like me protest peacefully, we get told to shut up and people try and put us back in what they think is our rightful place (for me, it's the closet). Stonewall and the Compton Cafe happened because we had enough.
 
Re: 2020 Democratic Challengers IV: Culling the Herd

So they should riot?

Riot:
take part in a violent public disturbance.
"students rioted in Paris"
synonyms: rampage, go on the rampage, run riot, take to the streets, fight in the streets, start a fight, raise an uproar, cause an affray, run/go wild, run amok, go berserk, fight, brawl, scuffle; informalraise hell
"the miners rioted and attacked the local Party HQ"

How is that any different than people criticizing the righties for the same sort of language?

That is such a straw man...very rarely are riots planned. It is almost always a more spontaneous response to something that happened.

And see we live in a society now filled with people who want harm done to protesters if they dare inconvenience them for 5 seconds so the voice of the people is being lost. That happens long enough and people are going to lash out. That doesnt make violence right, but if it was being done to me I cant say I would act the same way.

Riots are awful but sooner or later they might become a necessary means to an end. When protests and elections dont make things better you gotta be able to do something.
 
Re: 2020 Democratic Challengers IV: Culling the Herd

Rioting doesn't work. It's used as a pretext for repression, which is why violent protest is so often by paid agents of the Haves i9n order the de-legitimize protest.

Always remember the state has drilled into everyone that their use of force in defense of injustice is a sacred calling. Look at how cops and soldiers are lionized. On the other hand, any use of force in an attempt to end injustice is considered morally wrong and criminal and is punished with the most excessive violence the state can get away with.

Non-violence is The Way. The thugs and their rightwing supporters will always justify to themselves harming peaceful protesters, or simply flat out lie about it, but the mass of the voting public eventually puts down its remote or its iPacifier and starts paying attention when innocents are massacred by the state. The Left has to use non-violence. We have no other choice.
 
Re: 2020 Democratic Challengers IV: Culling the Herd

I was unclear. The accusation by fools was that if he supported Ttump at the start of his campaign, he should stand by Ttump forever or be branded a traitor. (Whereas it seems obvious to me that such awakenings ought to be encouraged and rewarded)
In all seriousness getting dragged on Twitter isn't exactly the end of the world and Twitter isn't representative of real life anyhow. I just find funny the people who think Republicans became a problem after Trump got elected and not before when they were genociding South America and the middle east, taking away peoples' safety nets, and being slightly less obvious about their racism, among other things.
 
Re: 2020 Democratic Challengers IV: Culling the Herd

In all seriousness getting dragged on Twitter isn't exactly the end of the world and Twitter isn't representative of real life anyhow. I just find funny the people who think Republicans became a problem after Trump got elected and not before when they were genociding South America and the middle east, taking away peoples' safety nets, and being slightly less obvious about their racism, among other things.

While it is sometimes harmless there has been plenty of cases where Twitter shaming has destroyed lives. Some really good books have been written on it. Twitter is a cesspool of people just looking to destroy people.

You are right though in this case. This myth that the GOP just became this evil is ridiculous. It has always been there, it just usually had some resistance from the Old Guard who just wanted to make money and not care. The second the Neo-Cons and Tea Partiers gained traction there was no going back.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top