Re: 2011 Minnesota Offseason Thread
I've got to agree with Scooby here. With a few exceptions, Lucia has rarely been the animated type on the bench during the game. It is usually aimed at the refs if he is acting emotional. It doesn't mean he's not intense with the team in the locker room though.
I was at practice a few times last week. Needless to say, neither Lucia or Guentzel were lacking in intensity. I could care less how he comes across in the media.
I also don't see the problem in a committee approach with a member of each class. It hardly means that players can't talk to the coach one on one. Especially with Guentzel back. He's always been a guy that players can talk to.
There's no doubt, Lucia has never been nearly as animated as Brooks, but he hasn't been a statue in the distant past either. My point is there's definitely been a change in his style over the past few seasons mainly for physical and psychological reasons and it adversely affected the program. The intensity and urgency of Guentzel will hopefully be infectious in that regard this season and yes, I agree he has always been a "go to guy" for players. But in my view, they ALL (including Grant Potulny) need to be the "go to guy" or this season will repeat its previous mistakes.
Whether you care or not how he appears to the media is not important to me or perhaps other fans. Gopher fans have endured some very disappointing seasons to the point where families who possessed season tickets for generations considered giving them up last season and I understand some did just that. IMO Lucia owes it to the fans to communicate through the press, in his first public appearance, a sense of urgency and passion and I was disappointed as I felt he failed to do that. He came up with the same canned approach he always does every season with little regard for clearly and enthusiastically communicating to the general public the absolute urgent need to get this program back on track. Guentzel did that very thing at the State Fair and I commend him for it.
As far as the representative of each class speaking weekly on behalf of others, that's obviously a band aid that is directly correlated with a psychological need...and that need is to "connect", which has been seriously lacking or they wouldn't be implementing it. Will it work? Maybe a bit, but I suspect not as well as they're speculating it will.
Over the last few years Lucia lost touch with one of the most important aspects of coaching...capturing the hearts of the players to such an extent that they WANT to give 110% every time they lace up. If you want to blame Hill for everything be my guest, but you'd be in denial. IMO, the inconsistent play and lack of solid work ethic of the past few seasons is mainly related to a collective disconnect of the psychological chemistry and demonstrated passion between the players and coaches. Now they're finally discovering that team chemistry is extremely personal and psychological, not just X's and O's, a team pizza party and filing a weekly report with the AD.
There's little doubt, as past press reports indicated, that Lucia was somewhat unapproachable and downright moody during his 18 month drug treatment phase from December, 2008 to June, 2010. As a personal trainer, I often hang out and train with very serious amateur and professional bodybuilders who sometimes take massive steroid hits, so I'm very familiar with the severe physical, psychosomatic and behavioral side effects of anabolic steroids which are similar in effect to corticosteroids. With the frequency (weekly) of the high mg. dosage levels that I understand Lucia was injecting...WOW...he was extremely fortunate to have avoided scandalizing himself, his family and the program more than he did. I've seen guys do some very crazy, violent stuff...
In order to avoid the instability of symptomatic affective and behavioral dysfunction caused from frequent and high dosages of steroid injections, an individual
MUST AT ALL TIMES engage in critically high levels of reflexivity and self monitoring while simultaneously struggling to maintain a stable self concept. That effectively translates into radical and self induced psychological adjustments in how you view yourself and relate to others. Lucia's initial spike of corticosteroids was dramatic and I suspect the following 18+ months of treatment required a significant recovery time once the treatment is discontinued because prolonged injections tend to saturate bodily tissues with toxic byproducts.
Although I sympathize with Don Lucia and his battle with this debilitating disease, I'm convinced that's precisely why his coaching style and ability to motivate players took a turn for the worse over the last couple seasons:
Lucia endured steroid treatments that kept him awake for two days at a time, then made him so listless he would sleep in his office until practice. The treatment began with four consecutive days of steroids -- "a real butt-kicker," Lucia recalled -- and a warning. People using the drug were advised to stay away from their workplaces, because they might say something they would regret. Within days, Lucia discovered that wasn't all.
During the first 48 hours after a treatment, he would be bouncing off the walls, unable to sleep. Then came a 48-hour crash. He became irritable and prone to flashes of anger. By Sunday, just as he began to feel normal, he knew the cycle would start all over.
"That first weekend we played at Mankato, and I was a madman," Lucia said. "The whole weekend, Joyce told the kids, 'Shhh. Dad's just gotten the steroids. Leave him alone.' It was so easy to get upset and angry.
"You can't sleep, you just can't. A [sleeping pill] wouldn't even make a dent. You're literally numb for a few days, then you're so tired. You're just kind of existing."
Assistant coach John Hill, who has worked with Lucia for 12 years, handled the damage control. He warned the players when Lucia was moody and reminded them not to take it personally. When opposing coaches and other people complained about Lucia's behavior, Hill apologized and explained the steroid effect.
That gave rise to an inside joke in the Gophers hockey office: If Lucia says you're fired, just laugh it off. The stressful atmosphere came to seem normal, but it took a toll.
"The first few days of the week, Don was like a raging bull," Hill said. "You hear about 'roid rage, and we witnessed it. Other days, he looked like he was ready to collapse."
"It was a very emotional time for all of us. Everyone did their best to stay upbeat and positive, for the kids and for each other. Really, we were just trying to survive on a daily basis."
There's little doubt in my mind, Don Lucia made a very serious error in judgment by not voluntarily heeding extant medical advice and taking a temporary leave of absence from coaching. He could have mentored from a distance and come back with renewed vision. Instead that corporate decision with Maturi consequently damaged the program's reputation, the fan base, potential player relationships and their development, and demonstrated a stubborn disregard for the financial stewardship of the Gopher mens hockey program at the University of Minnesota. Sadly, he's never admitted to his critics that he made a calculated and colossal mistake but simply states, "We haven't been where we've wanted to be the last few years". That's not good leadership...pure and simple.
Now that the steroid phase appears to be over (although neurosarcoidosis can be mysteriously chronic even after initial remission and recidivism is possible at any time), he needs to find a way to "connect" to players again, demonstrate passionate sound leadership and bring this program back to the winning tradition of Gopher hockey.