Out of curiosity...
Bigger sieve:
Carey Price
Chris Osgood (last 2 seasons only)
Christobal Huet
Brian Boucher
Honestly a tough question.
Price is among the most overrated goaltenders in the last 10 years.
Huet is a neverwas that managed to get paid like a star goaltender before exposing himself as a fraud.
Osgood was good at many points throughout his career but has, in the past two seasons, allowed a rookie and a career backup to look like Brodeur and Roy compared to him.
Boucher was, to me, always a backup goaltender that was, at times, forced into the #1 role and hasn't really been able to sustain anything reasonably worth being "ok" about.
I think it is a hard choice. I guess I'd go with Osgood simply because he has the distinction of being at one time, a great goaltender. The fact that he's fallen off so incredibly hardcore... wow.