Gm. Per heisenberg. Jesse Allecia has decommited from UNH. He's averaging a point a game in the Q and was my second best player coming in next year. We all know at this point UNH will never win anything with the current coaching staff intact. Look at the regression from players this year it's very sad. The kicker on Allecia is he's already committed to Dartmouth, that didn't take long. Another head scratcher is he's signed Kyle Hoyles and not Nico Tournas to a NIL. head scratching stuff.
So he accepted an opportunity to play D1 hockey in the Ivy League most likely for full financial aid instead of opting for UNH. Seems logical. Why are you knocking the coaches for this one?
So ... last time I checked, Dartmouth has been running a D-1 Men's Hockey program for many, many years now. Definitely for sure at the time the Allecia kid originally committed to UNH. Which of course means Allecia originally decided that UNH was his best D-1 option for the future. With me so far, potty??
Now we move ahead a year or two ... Allecia decommits from UNH, and in a relatively short time period, he is re-committed to Dartmouth. What changed? Here are a few things we know for sure:
- Dartmouth was (and still is) an Ivy League school
- UNH wasn't (and still isn't) an Ivy League school
- The Dartmouth coaching staff hasn't materially changed in several years
- The UNH coaching staff hasn't materially changed in several years
So at some point recently, Allecia obviously had a change of heart. You are only speculating that it had something to do with a better offer package ("most likely for full financial aid") which is your usual "straw man", constructed specifically to support your UNH-friendly conclusion. But you dismiss other reasons:
- The Dartmouth coaching staff is able to point to a steady upwards progression of their results, year to year (including a 4-0-0 start this season)
- The UNH coaching staff is unable to point to any upwards progression of their results, year to year (including a mediocre 4-5-0 start this season)
- UNH Men's Hockey has experienced an above-average volume of decommits during the Coach Souza era
The overall weight of evidence on the usual factors leans heavily on the likelihood that Allecia lost faith in his selection of UNH, weighed in comparison to Dartmouth, and with the quick turnover suggesting Dartmouth was likely in the mix originally when he first selected UNH. Of course, there is also the weight of feedback from advisors and other trusted hockey contacts (coaches, players on other teams, etc.) where Reid Cashman can point to a growing program, whereas Mike Souza can only point to a stagnating program that he is convinced will be growing positively in the future, despite a decade of evidence to the contrary.
In the end, RB is very likely correct. UNH is going to need to go in another direction in order to return to their prior level of success. MS7 has had two major changes of circumstances that offered him an excuse (or per you, an explanation) as to why his program hasn't been successful. One, "Shrink The Rink" has now failed. Two, the new Canadian Junior recruiting strategy, is not showing any immediate results, and that all told points to one thing - limited D-1 coaching ability. Advisors know that. Other coaches that interact within and around the D-1 hockey circles know that. And eventually, players and recruits know, too.
It's really not all that complicated, is it potty?!? Unless of course you have an agenda, and all arguments must be bent to jam forcibly into said agenda ...