But, you were fine with Danny Tirone starting nearly every game in his last three seasons (2015/16-2017/18, 105 games; 6180 mins; 9-19-6, 3.19, 0.907; 15-18-5, 2.99, 0.910; 10-17-6, 2.68, 0.917), right? Tirone split time in net his first year (20 games, 14-6, 2.14, 0.924) with Adam Clark (1-Adam-12), arguably Tyrone’s best season. But, wow those were bad UNH teams at the close of the Umile Era.
That's a fair point Snives, so let me differentiate the two situations a bit. At the start of the 2014/2015 season, Umile's plan was to ride Casey DeSmith as the lead goalie, a job he had earned by out playing Matt DiGirolamo (sp?) in CDS' frosh season, and continued as the lead dog over the next two seasons, backed up by the rarely used Jeff Wyer, with Jamie Regan as the #3 guy in what turned out to be CDS' final season in Titletown. The original UNH plan for 2014/2015 was for Adam Clark to step in as the #2 goalie behind CDS, replacing Wyer. Then Labor Day Weekend happened, and CDS was out of the picture, leaving Umile with Clark as the (unexpected) #1, and Regan bumped up to #2. Tirone was originally slotted in as the #1 for the following season after CDS' anticipated graduation, so he was not enrolled at UNH for the start of the 2014/2015 season. Tirone was then enrolled for the second semester, and at the break UNH was not doing terribly well, several games under .500 and Clark, while performing admirably under the circumstances, was no Casey DeSmith. So Tirone came in after the break, and provided much-improved goaltending, bringing UNH back up to at or near .500. UNH swept UConn in the MBPBEGAM round, and then stunned Providence in the quarters to advance to the Garden, where (in their last visit to the facility) they lost to eventual champs BU (and Jack Eichel) in the semis.
In that season where you describe Tirone and Clark as "splitting time",
the only "split" was that Clark played most/all of the games pre-Tirone, and Tirone got all of the starts when he arrived at midseason. Which was apparently how Coach Umile expected things to be the following few seasons. Tirone fell short of CDS, but he's been the best UNH goalie since CDS (including Hellsten two seasons ago). Tirone unfortunately played behind late stage Umile era teams those final 3 seasons, which were pretty terrible. I don't recall there being an issue with Tirone wilting on the second games of a weekend series, and I don't believe there was any indication that he crumbled late in the season due to overwork. My clear recollection is that coming out of the break that final Umile season (also Tirone's last), with everyone well rested, the 'Cats inexplicably went on an extended losing streak that cost Coach Umile his shot at the NRN, just when it seemed he couldn't possibly fall short.
Looking at Chauvette and Whale in their pre-UNH D-1 seasons ... Chauvette (the NH kid) came home after two years of being the regular starter at Union, and this will be his fourth and final year of D-1 eligibility (I believe?) with him now being the go-to guy at UNH. Whale was a back-up in his frosh season at UAA and took the reins as the 1A goalie as a soph, before coming over to UNH as the go-to guy last season to replace Hellsten, who returned to Sweden relatively late in the offseason. Whale's pre-UNH numbers are slightly better than KC's numbers (looking at save pct.) although Chauvette's early UNH numbers this season are superior to Whale's UNH numbers last season. If Whale doesn't get steamrolled at BC last season, would KC even be here? I don't know that answer.
Coaches always know more than they let on to the public, and one possibility that hasn't been raised to date is
whether Whale might not be entirely cleared to resume full speed, real game action? I'm assuming both he and #3 guy Kristian Coombs have been dressing as back-ups for the first 9 games, no? I'm not up to speed on the current "redshirt" rules, but it's possible that Souza is gonna ride Chauvette all season long, and use Coombs as an emergency back-up, with the possibility of having Whale return for a shot at #1 next season - unless KC falters or gets hurt?? I'm not on top of the current recruiting, one of the casualties of 'Watcher spending his free time elsewhere these days, so I don't know if that makes any sense, especially for a program that has gone with different transfer goalies in each of the last three seasons? Long term planning for that position seems to have gone south since Drew Commesso.
However you look at it, the case of the missing Whale is curious, and arguably getting curiouser by each weekend that passes without him taking the ice ...