Was there a good Israel strategy, though?
We had painted ourselves into a corner by being their weapon sugar daddy for 60 years to keep the oil flowing. What was anybody going to do? Typically when you have an ally who goes insane you can threaten to pull up stakes or even switch sides. The Israelis understand with the way lobbying and media work in the US that is never an option. Given how we sold supporting Israel to the public as an Imperative Moral Crusade, we can't go back without both parties admitting, "Oh, that stuff we told you since the 50s? That was all lies. It was just geopolitics and the equations have changed. Sorry."
This is not like freezing out the Germans in the 30s despite there being a huge and politically savvy German population in the US. Pointing out Israel's crimes has always been a third rail here for various reasons, a few laudable, most deeply cynical.
Without a plausible threat of withdrawing support and/or backing a different regional power, the US had (has) no way to control Israel. We have no choice but to keep shoveling money and arms into that black hole. It's like shoring up New Orleans.