Fishman'81
Black Bear since D-2
Yes, but you have to make sure they are evenly distributed amongst the student population. Otherwise, you get into the situation which got schools like Geneseo, Potsdam, Buffalo State, and most recently Elmira into trouble.
The Ivies are a peculiar situation. By the NCAA rules, they have every right to offer scholarships. They are full fledged D1 members. It is their own institutional and league decision to not offer scholarships. So, how they police that is entirely up to them. The NCAA has nothing to do with that.
I actually have no problem with that calculus, as disingenuous as it is at face-value. The Ivies have always cheated, too, they just cheated more effectively.
Seems to me that all those across-the-board BS "rules" will fly out of the window very soon. There's always a work-around for the athletes anyway. We've seen at the D-3 level plenty of times, even when no real money was involved... And big-time D-1 sports? Forget about any integrity there.
These days, with the name/image/likeness policy, and adding-on the transfer portal, why even pretend that college sports are "amateur" endeavors anyway? It's going to be a dog-eat-dog deal, and to Hell with the hindmost. That might even happen to a tiny extent in D-3 hockey. (As in, a local commercial for this or that).
Personally, I don't have an issue with it. I can't imagine a star player in ANY D-3 hockey school lining his pockets via that sort of thing, but I think he should be allowed to test the waters; maybe sell a used car or tout a pizzeria to pick up a few bucks.
Last edited: