Re: UNH Wildcats 2015 Offseason - Future Planning ...or Just Rearranging the Deck Cha
Chuck who knows what was said to Coach Stewart when he was hired..but we do know what was said to Coach Souza. I mean, one can assume he was told something to the tune of "one day in the near future the HC job will be open"? He had to know going in that this of course was a possibility given Coach U's age; there's an end somewhere.
Do we
really know what Souza was told? In reading through the quoted passage in my last post, even Souza's description of what he was "sort of" told really never goes beyond having the aforementioned "opportunity". But having said that ... with the various hedges and contingencies apparently given to Souza, would it be shocking to you if we found out Stewart was told the same thing last year? I'm 100% positive the idea that Coach Umile's time at UNH was coming to a close would have been a HUGE factor for both coaches to decide to come back to Durham.
I know Al Pike's article was headlined "Heir Apparent", but if I was his editor - with that story on my desk - I would have added a question mark to the end of the headline. But that's just me. Anyway ...
I think it's safe to assume that the UNH job was a leg up for Stewart (nothing personal MC fans) being his alma mater and all, and he was happy to get closer to where his family is from (his words at a FOMH event). And one could assume Stewart has HC aspirations; I mean, don't most AC's? Or maybe he's quite happy to be here, in this position.
I think the highlighted part is the crucial question - is he here and happy as an assistant OR does he still harbor hopes of a HC job at this level? Let's look at the profiles of the three guys who would have been the logical "heir apparents" over the last year or so ...
* Borek - in his mid 50's, basically has been coaching D-1 hockey for most of the last 30 years. First 10 years as an assistant, then a six year stint as HC at Lake State in the post-Jeff Jackson *dynasty* era, and then the last dozen or so years at UNH where he probably had some opportunities at other D-1 HC jobs at some point and bypassed them. So now he's pretty much locked in as a D-1 assistant "lifer" with a last bold move to Providence. At some point, it's hard not to think there was some discussion between Umile and Borek (with OR without Scarano, or with Umile as a go-between) about Umile's long-range retirement plans, and whether Borek would be considered for the "opportunity" (that word again!) if/when the time arrived. Maybe that discussion took place years ago ... or maybe it took place a couple of months ago? The idea that he popped up in PC, and Souza arrived at UNH within days/weeks seems more than coincidence.
* Stewart - in his mid 40's, and has been a D-1 assistant for 12 years now - 6 of those years in Hockey East. I believe he is 8 years older than Souza, and had five (5) years into Merrimack - during a time when Merrimack was enjoying its best years in the program's history - when he returned to UNH. As a player, he put most of a decade into the low minors as an undrafted player, whereas Souza was drafted and spent most of his North American pro career at the AHL level before heading off for Europe. But to say UNH was a "step up" from Merrimack - while arguably true due to his alum status, then that would go double for Souza, who only had two years (1 HE) into UConn, no?
Souza - in his late 30's, and has been a D-1 assistant coach for four (4) years - and say what you will about UConn, but they have not yet experienced the success of Merrimack's teams during Stewart's time with that program. One clear advantage he can claim is that as a player, he experienced hockey at a higher level that Stewart, no question about it. I'm sure that makes a difference in Souza's favor ... but just how much, when guys like Umile, Parker, York, Bazin, Walshy and Leaman seemed to manage without the NHL/AHL pedigree? Maybe Souza is the young guy who is making his chops in the recruiting game, and if so, then I'm the last person on the board to comment on how good he is at that job compared to Stewart or anyone else.
So much could happen in the next 3 years, we could wildly speculate. Maybe Stewart picks up a HC job elsewhere? Heck maybe Mike Souza does. (hey it could happen..but I'm doubting that?) It's obvious that many AC's move laterally; look at Borek. But Stewart is a much younger man (isn't he?) than Borek so he could be eyeing the big job eventually, but not at UNH, not at least, in this "3 year" timeframe that you doubt will happen anyway. And that's a whole other thing, isn't it.
And therein lies the rub. Did Stewart come back to UNH to get himself in line to be Coach Umile's successor, and if he did - was he given any assurances of an "opportunity"? Hard to believe he would have left Merrimack after 5 relatively successful seasons without at least some suggestions he would be in the mix for consideration if/when Umile retires. The idea that he came back for travel reasons sounds pretty lame to me - the distance between North Andover and Durham is not exactly staggering - and it's certainly a closer commute than Melrose to Durham, for pertinent comparison. I think the question will answer itself ... but putting myself in Coach Stewart's shoes, and hearing all of the chatter about a younger, less experienced assistant in recent weeks, I'd be asking some pretty direct pointed questions about my future to my boss(es) already. Unless of course I'd already sorted that out long ago. Time will tell.
Personally, I believe this is the timeframe for Coach U to end his career, although that remains to be seen I suppose. Seems Souza was told that...and I bet he's counting on it.
I've said before, and I'll say it again at the risk of sounding foolish (a fear I've long ago gotten over

) ... IF UNH gets things turned back around and is competing on a national level over these next three seasons, I don't think Coach Umile is going to walk away so long as he has a legitimate shot at the D-1 title. He's put too much time into the program, and come too close to walk away if he thinks glory is just around the corner. And I have no issue with that whatsoever.
But again, I ask ... IF Souza was offered insights into Coach Umile's future as part of his decision to come back to his alma mater, is it logical to assume Stewart did not have the same questions (and would have been given similar insights) when he was hired last year?
Unless Stewart was incredibly naïve and/or Souza was much more savvy, it's hard to imagine both guys not receiving the same kinds of feedback to their likely questions about their prospects at UNH that led to them changing jobs.
If Stewart simply doesn't have the driving desire to be the UNH Head Coach, and is happy as an assistant, then this may be a non-issue. IF Stewart does have those ambitions, and feels slighted by the apparent "heir apparent" publicity that was given to Souza recently that was not given to him last year ... it's hard to see him sticking around much longer than this season before moving on. JMHO.