Chuck Murray
WIS & Effingwoods Hockey Almanac
Leadership is key
Leadership is key
The "two captain model" definitely works better if one doesn't effectively get himself kicked off the team at midseason. I'm sure Coach Umile would like to have had a mulligan on the Charlebois selection. But stuff happens.
There is no set answer to this question. All depends on the team, and the players involved. I have a lot of time for kids like Butler, Collins, Fornataro and Ciocco ... but truth be told, the last really strong captain UNH has had was Patrick Foley. I gave Coach Umile tons of credit back then for having the guts and belief in Foley to factor him into a formal leadership role for 3 years - something you see VERY rarely, but something that clearly worked for that player and those teams. It would have been nice to see Butler get at least an "A" for his junior season. He certainly proved himself worthy.
Getting your leadership choices right is one of the biggest decisions the coach of ANY team can make. And any coach/program that just follows a boilerplate approach (i.e. we will pick two seniors, one "C" and one "A" every season, or something similar) is really missing the boat big-time. JMHO.
Leadership is key
Over the last two seasons, the captains seemed to have set the tone and helped to define the character of the teams. Both teams developed a pattern of working hard on most shifts and not letting down when falling behind in a game - especially in the NCAA tournament. This was particularly true this season. For each of the last two years, there were two captains:
08-09: Greg Collins & Joe Charlebois![]()
![]()
09-10: Bobby Butler & Peter LeBlanc
During the 07-08 and 06-07 seasons, there was only one captain; Matt Fornataro and Josh Ciocco, respectively. My recollection is that these teams had untimely lapses in effort - again, especially in the NCAA playoffs.
I wonder whether a two captain model works better than one captain with one or more assistants.
The "two captain model" definitely works better if one doesn't effectively get himself kicked off the team at midseason. I'm sure Coach Umile would like to have had a mulligan on the Charlebois selection. But stuff happens.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7a5e8/7a5e80f7b48c588b184c6616a76ba94b98cadc59" alt="Frown :( :("
There is no set answer to this question. All depends on the team, and the players involved. I have a lot of time for kids like Butler, Collins, Fornataro and Ciocco ... but truth be told, the last really strong captain UNH has had was Patrick Foley. I gave Coach Umile tons of credit back then for having the guts and belief in Foley to factor him into a formal leadership role for 3 years - something you see VERY rarely, but something that clearly worked for that player and those teams. It would have been nice to see Butler get at least an "A" for his junior season. He certainly proved himself worthy.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0dd6/a0dd67a17ec8b6e6bcb45d7047f3d9bfe87084bb" alt="Smile :) :)"
Getting your leadership choices right is one of the biggest decisions the coach of ANY team can make. And any coach/program that just follows a boilerplate approach (i.e. we will pick two seniors, one "C" and one "A" every season, or something similar) is really missing the boat big-time. JMHO.