I'd rather UNH focus on the issues it has on hand rather than waste time, energy and budget on a tournament whose outcome is nothing more than a a glorified participation trophy.
The risk of UNH's reputation going lower than it's current status as a perennial Hockey East cellar dweller by playing in this proposed tournament is acute. The program is a borderline laughingstock as it is, let's not put the final nail in a once proud program by losing to St. A's or SNHU.
Gosh, that's an uncharacteristically defensive approach to take, Grouch ... others have raised it before in the past, but coming from you, I'm honestly surprised. Let's look at it this way ... if there's no reputation to speak of at the present time, what's to be lost here for UNH?? How do you potentially get the two NH D-2's genuinely involved, if they don't think they've got a semi-realistic shot at winning a game? Now may actually be the best time, if such a tourney went the local D-2's route (SNHU and St. A's). Pair up UNH and Dartmouth in the Friday night late game, the two D-2's in the early game, and guarantee one of the D-2's a win, and a trip to Saturday's Finals against one of the big fish. Imagine the push that could be generated at both of the smaller schools to upgrade to Atlantic Hockey D-1 play if one (or both?) of them had success? And if UNH loses, so what? It's a non-conference game, maybe even an exhibition game if there are restrictions on D-1's playing D-2's? Maybe the best thing that could happen - for everyone - would be for an incredible SHNU tourney win?
First year of "Connecticut Ice", with three legit D-1 programs and Sacred Heart from Atlantic Hockey ... guess who won it? Yup, Sacred Heart. Year 2 was lost to COVID and that could have killed the whole concept right there ... but no one was embarrassed to pull the plug. They resumed a year later, and now it's five years in, three different champs, and Year Six coming up. They've gone back-and-forth a couple times on neutral site vs. rotating home sites (where it currently stands) so they're still working out the kinks. Yale has yet to win it. Is Yale embarrassed? Apparently not. Why should UNH be embarrassed then??
If the D-2 thing becomes a start-up hurdle, then maybe you start it as UNH, Dartmouth, Merrimack (closest other D-1 to Manch) and Bentley (closest AHA D-1). Pretty much the same thing as "CT Ice", four teams, three leagues, so minimal impact to your non-conference options if you're UNH or MC. Bentley likely would jump at a future HEA or ECAC offer, and they brought a pretty good contingent up to Manch for the Regionals this Spring, while Merrimack would be a given so long as Scotty B is around, and has a chance to rub UNH's nose in it. Hope that it takes root, and continue with that group until one of the local D-2's decides to upgrade to an AHA program. If Borek isn't still at MC, maybe they lose interest, and drop out? Bentley would still keep it at 3 different D-1 leagues.
The "CT Ice" thing took a couple of years' advance planning to make it happen. Likely would be the same for Riverstone 2.0. The advanced booking for SNHU Arena is pretty quiet this year, but in the past they've had Boston Pops and Trans Siberian holiday musical events in early December (this year it's comedy and PBR for example) so the facility would have way more flexibility now than if/when they eventually get another pro sports tenant in there.
And let's say two years of planning - which just so happens to coincide with the expiration of the current UNH HC's contract - could stand as a celebration of an extension OR a fresh new start for the next HC. Also gives the current AD something to kibbitz about with fellow AD's, rather than sweating over W's and L's for her various programs. Might even look good on a CV or resume for a future employer further up the food chain?
All this stuff is out there to be had. Or we can just stick with mid-Decembers against the Browns and Army West Points of the world in a half-filled Whitt, 'cuz at least then no one will be around to witness any further embarrassment(s).
I've so far spoken with the U-L sports editor, someone at Mayor Ruais' office, and one former HC who also happens to be an alum at one of the four proposed participating schools. None of them seem to think this is a crazy idea. Question is, who would be the person to take the lead, and "carry the torch"? Doubtful that some hockey junkie from Effingwoods is gonna have the necessary pull to make this happen, but I'll probably keep talking about it 'til someone surfaces ...
