I agree with you that Borek deserves to win but Barr certainly deserves to be in the conversation.
Not only was Maine picked last in the poll, they finished last the prior season. They won 7 games in 2021-2022 and won 15 in 2022-2023. Merrimack was a good team last year finishing 5th and having 19 wins. Currently they are at 22 and counting.
Since there are 3 nominations, Barr deserves to be one of them. Maine had 16 new players this season and still had themselves in the picture down the stretch. What Borek has done using the portal is pretty extraordinary, especially at a school that doesn't have a ton of hockey history. Merrimack has definitely found their guy and will be relevant as long as he's there.
I would agree with this in its entirety. Barr absolutely deserves to be a finalist, just as much as Borek absolutely deserves to be the winner. Doubling the win total and rising five spots in the standings is more than worthy of a finalist nomination.