What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

Borrowed from elsewhere

Imma be cynical for a moment here, but I think McCain's speech was more after-the-fact justification.

I suspect what went down was more like this:

McCain returned to the Senate not for health care, but for the National Defense Authorization Act.

The quid pro quo McConnell was offering McCain in exchange for his vote on repeal was an agreement to take up the NDAA immediately after the health vote so he could shepherd that through passage before he had to leave again for treatment.

Rand Paul had some issues with the NDAA, was assured by McCain's office that those would be addressed via regular order, but that wasn't enough - he objected to the fast-tracking of the NDAA, which prevents the Senate from taking it up in time for McCain to do anything about it.

So McCain voted against repeal as a middle finger to Rand Paul.
 
LOL. Understatement of the Year.




No. The situation has changed a lot. They used to be able to go to that well because OBAMACARE ARGLE BARGLE, but now even the dullest knife in the drawer realizes that repeal will throw millions of people and their children off insurance and effectively end their health care.

The GOP needed to pull this off without any public debate because the facts kill them. They didn't accomplish that. This fiasco educated a lot of people about the actuals of Obamacare and Medicare, and that is very bad news for the GOP.

Yes, they can still use it as an irritant to get Fox suckers to donate money and time and votes, but the pool of those suckers shrinks every day.

The path forward for the GOP is to use Obamacare that way on the sly with their sheep, but with the larger electorate start darkly warning about the Democrats and TEH SOCIALISM!!! of Single Payer. There is still such global electoral ignorance about Medicare for All that they can squeeze another few cycles of right wing poutrage out of that before health care goes the way of social security and they have to find a new whipping boy.

Agree on the sad ignorance of single payer. That would have been a much better and cheaper way forward than either Obamacare or Trumpcare.

I really think democrats are foolish to ignore the people getting a raw deal from Obamacare. There need to be changes made so their costs are at a reasonable level. The dems should start pushing legislation to show they have solutions even if there isn't much chance of it passing right now.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

I really think democrats are foolish to ignore the people getting a raw deal from Obamacare.

This is another potential strategy: concern trolling. It helps turn the attention off the GOP and back where they want it to be: "Those Democrats are out of touch!!!" And it is attractive because it puts off the tough self-criticism that Republicans need to eventually suck up and do.

The GOP has stepped in it, Drew. They've inculcated a worldview in their supporters where compromise is weakness or even treason, and that prevents them from getting anything done. They say demonstrably false things for applause lines and to prime donations, but then can't deliver because no one can: the world they paint does not exist. They spent multiple generations building their Parallel Universe and pushing their voters into it. Now they are stuck.

The Democrats have been ceded the field of reality and really all we need to do is operate within it and tell the truth. Voters don't reward truth, Walter Mondale and Ronald Reagan demonstrated 33 years ago that between a hard truth and a pretty lie voters will pick the lie. But they do reward competence indirectly when things run more smoothly and right now we're the only side that even has a hope of competence because we're the only side living in reality.
 
Last edited:
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

I really think democrats are foolish to ignore the people getting a raw deal from Obamacare. There need to be changes made so their costs are at a reasonable level. The dems should start pushing legislation to show they have solutions even if there isn't much chance of it passing right now.

Listen to any Democrat. None of them say that the ACA is perfect. All of them are willing to work the parts that people are having problems with.

What it takes for them to work on that are republicans willing to do that.

IMHO, it's foolish to throw out the ACA because it's not perfect for everyone out of the gate. Anything can be fixed.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

Listen to any Democrat. None of them say that the ACA is perfect. All of them are willing to work the parts that people are having problems with.

What it takes for them to work on that are republicans willing to do that.

IMHO, it's foolish to throw out the ACA because it's not perfect for everyone out of the gate. Anything can be fixed.

Not to mention that at least half of what's wrong with ObamaCare is directly the result of the GOP intentionally sabotaging it.
 
This is another potential strategy: concern trolling. It helps turn the attention off the GOP and back where they want it to be: "Those Democrats are out of touch!!!" And it is attractive because it puts off the tough self-criticism that Republicans need to eventually suck up and do.

The GOP has stepped in it, Drew. They've inculcated a worldview in their supporters where compromise is weakness or even treason, and that prevents them from getting anything done. They say demonstrably false things for applause lines and to prime donations, but then can't deliver because no one can: the world they paint does not exist. They spent multiple generations building their Parallel Universe and pushing their voters into it. Now they are stuck.

The Democrats have been ceded the field of reality and really all we need to do is operate within it and tell the truth. Voters don't reward truth, Walter Mondale and Ronald Reagan demonstrated 33 years ago that between a hard truth and a pretty lie voters will pick the lie. But they do reward competence indirectly when things run more smoothly and right now we're the only side that even has a hope of competence because we're the only side living in reality.

I think saying America has stepped in it might be a better description. You're unfortunately right about the Republican Party. They've lost the plot and it's not very obvious how they get their act together. This is by no means an endorsement of the democrats. If there was ever a time to launch a mainstream third party surely it is now.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

Not to mention that at least half of what's wrong with ObamaCare is directly the result of the GOP intentionally sabotaging it.

Of course. Ever since Turtle Boy and the Bone Man took over the Democrats haven't been able to Govern ****.
 
Did the three republican nos campaign on a straight up repeal? This would have lead to millions more without insurance and 20% higher premiums. Only the nuttiest senators actually wanted this. The rest knew it was **** but they voted for it because they hoped it would fail but they could still tell their brain dead GOP voters they tried to stick it to that Kenyan Muslim.

Agreeing to pass something only if the house promised not to pass it? Your party is a joke. They don't give a **** about fixing anything or helping anyone but the rich. And sticking it to the democrats and specifically ****ting on anything to do with Obama.

The party is not a joke. The leadership needs to be replaced.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

The party is not a joke. The leadership needs to be replaced.

Oh, yes it is. Have you read the platform? Have you seen what Walker and Brownback have done? Have you seen some of the **** Texas has pulled? How about North Carolina. They are a JOKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Are you drunk? There is no way they would get praise from the R side, Hate Radio and Fox would have a field day and moderate Rs would all get primaried from the far right.
McCain is dying and will be replaced by either some bot-like replacement or a Democrat.

Collins isn't getting primaried like stated by others.

Murkowski will either get primaried and run independently again and win or be replaced by a Democrat because the Republican candidate will be a nut job. But Murkowski has 5 years to reelection and that's enough time to build a warchest to make sure she won't get primaried.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

The party is not a joke. The leadership needs to be replaced.

I agree it's not a joke. The GOP is a step to the right away from a white nationalist fascist party. That's not the leadership, it's the rank and file.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

McCain is dying and will be replaced by either some bot-like replacement or a Democrat.

I haven't lived in AZ for about a decade, but they aren't electing a D Senator for probably another decade or more.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

I think saying America has stepped in it might be a better description. You're unfortunately right about the Republican Party. They've lost the plot and it's not very obvious how they get their act together. This is by no means an endorsement of the democrats. If there was ever a time to launch a mainstream third party surely it is now.

The Democrats have been the centrist mainstream party ever since Bill Clinton. What we need is for both parties to slide to the left and become a reasonable left and a reasonable right, and then to gently oscillate between those two. What we have had for twenty years is staggering jolts between a center platform and a radical right wing Utopian political experiment that has failed.
 
I haven't lived in AZ for about a decade, but they aren't electing a D Senator for probably another decade or more.
Name recognition is a big thing in politics and I'd doubt there are very many Rs in Arizona that have name recognition that aren't fully nutty.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

She has much more to worry about in a primary than general election. I wouldn't be shocked to see Brakey win in 2018 and LePage win in 2020. I think the people who are getting screwed by Obamacare(they exist) are much more passionate about voting than those who are benefiting. In a lot of ways I think the vote failing will be a boon to republicans next year. The bill wouldn't have helped many people had it passed and now they can still use it as an issue to run on.

There is no way that no name Brakey is going to beat Angust King, also one of the most popular senators.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

The party is not a joke. The leadership needs to be replaced.
Joe, you seem more like an old-school, traditional Republican than the newer alt-right, Tea Bagger model. As such, the thinking displayed in your posts contains the usual gaping logical shortcomings, profound lack of awareness, and refusal to connect even the most connectable of dots if it doesn’t suit your position but stops way short of the literally insane, outright fascist lunacy that’s in favor in the party at this time. (Tangent, how do you not see that you have far more in common with the current Democratic Party than this collection of sociopaths? Is it really a case of “I decided at 18 I was a Republican and it would be a sign of weakness to ever change that”? This isn’t Red Sox / Yankees for godssake, it’s slightly more important, and bottom line, your party left you, that’s already happened, done deal, for you to not see that or act accordingly is a whole other level of psychology that needs looking into.)

There are 3 animating principles of the Republican Party, and only 3:
• Do anything and everything to enrich their plutocrat masters
• Oppose anything any liberal ever said might even slightly be a good idea (clean water is now a liberal thing…?)
• Dismantle anything the Kenyan Muslim did

(And even those last 2 are more for chits and giggles than anything else, and are never to interfere with the first one.)

Education, health care, clean air/water, the rule of law, upward mobility, peace – no interest whatsoever. That’s not just a party leadership thing, that goes to the marrow of the party. That is who they are. I know self-delusion has always been a big favorite with conservatives but some of you old-school guys are taking it to a new extreme with your continued, knee-jerk support of a party that was hi-jacked from you wholesale over the last 15 years.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

The party is not a joke. The leadership needs to be replaced.

yeah, if only they were more effective in ****ing over the poor and middle class at the expense of the wealthy then they would be real leaders! You're sitting there lamenting the fact that the leadership couldn't push through a bill to kick millions off insurance and raise premiums for everyone else.

you don't give a **** about how awful the Republican platform is because they throw you an occasional bone on abortion. It's really quite pathetic.
 
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

The GOP is a step to the right away from a white nationalist fascist party. That's not the leadership, it's the rank and file.

We would not have gotten Palin and Trump without the rank and file.
 
Last edited:
Re: The PPACA Thread Part V: Doctor! Doctor! Give me the news!

There is no way that no name Brakey is going to beat Angust King, also one of the most popular senators.

Are the democrats going to run someone? If they do that gives Brakey a decent opportunity. I really think King has been a huge disappointment. He marketed himself as someone who was going to bridge the divide in the senate and has been completely useless. Does he ever not vote with the democrats? Has he had one meaningful accomplishment?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top