I remember Tim bringing in guys with gaudy stats that couldn't skate or play D. I suspect Barr would have dropped Josh if he didn't think he could play in HE.
That's tough to do when the younger brother is the crown jewel. Drop the other brother and maybe you lose both. Not like I have seen either of them play but the numbers from the 17 year old really stand out. I wasn't suggesting the older brother can't play. Just that the younger brother has to be one of the best recruits you've had in some time.