Re: Super Bowl XLVIII and NFL Thread: Sherman's March to Jersey
I was thinking before the game that Peyton's legacy should be fine regardless of the outcome. After that debacle I think his legacy should be tarnished forever. That has got to be the worse prep for a Super Bowl by a team since Minnesota played the Raiders.
Some nerd out there needs to develop a "quality of SB win" metric.
So, think of the Super Bowl winners. I'd have to put Terry Bradshaw in a category all by himself for beating a stellar 70's Dallas team...TWICE. Were it not for the Steelers Dallas would have 7 Super Bowl victories right now. His other two victories were against chokers (0-4 Vikings) and the Rams who weren't heard from again after their SB until they were in St. Louis.
Montana beat a pretty good Miami team (Marino's only SB appearance), and two decent Bengals teams. To his credit, and why he's a better QB than Brady despite all the bleatings of my fellow Pats fans, is that I don't recall him making a bonehead interception or taking an idiotic safety during any of those games. In both Bengals games, doing that could have led to defeat.
Brady beat a great Rams team and a good Eagles team. Carolina = Rams of '79. However he inexplicably lost twice to an okay and then a good Giants team in which he's most responsible for blowing the game with bad passes.
Rothlesberger beat two bad teams that had no business being there (Seattle & Arizona). In one he was awful, in the other stellar.
Elway beat a great team in the Packers and a one shot wonder vs Atlanta. However he was terrible in his 3 losses to a good Giants team, a good Redskins team and a great SF team.
Manning beat one of the worst teams to ever make the Super Bowl in the Bears. He lost to a good New Orleans team and a very good Seattle team. For anyone to claim he's the best ever in light of this has to be joking. He's more like Brett Favre, a guy who beat a decent Patriots team and then lost to a great Denver team and never made it back.
Oh forgot about Aikman! I think he beat the Buffalo chokers twice and then a decent Steelers team with Neil O'Donnell at QB who single handed blew the game with two picks that looked like he was throwing the game.