Plattsburgh State had just one loss to a ranked team before this weekend, but it didn't have any wins versus the elites, settling instead for three ties.
The Cardinals broke through Saturday against the No. 3 team in Division III men's hockey and claimed the Cardinal Classic title in the process.
Jake Mooney scored with 5:08 left for a 2-1 come-from-behind victory against Castleton.
"We've played a lot of the better teams really tough, for sure, but we've been getting a lot of ties against the good teams," Mooney said. "So it's nice to finally get a win against a really good team."
Castleton goaltender Erick Cinotti was named the tournament MVP. He made 40 saves Saturday and totaled 82 on the weekend. Paul Puglisi, Kyle Kudroch and Alex Jensen represented Plattsburgh on the All-Tournament team, while Castleton's Dru Douglas and Utica's Tim Coffman also made the squad.
Utica defeated Babson, 6-2, in the first game Saturday.
Castleton (11-2) will return to Stafford Ice Arena on Friday for another shot at the Cardinals.
No. 5 Plattsburgh (8-2-3) is unbeaten in its last six games.
"I like the way we played (Saturday)," Plattsburgh coach Bob Emery said. "I thought we played with a lot of speed, and I thought we did a good job on the attacks. I thought we did a good job on offense."
After a scoreless first period, the Cardinals held a 20-10 shot advantage in the second. They had a number of good chances, including two Kudroch shots that hit the iron.
But the Spartans got on the board first when the puck bounced to Brett Zeggil right in front of Mathieu Cadieux, and Zeggil flipped a soft shot over the Plattsburgh goalie with nine minutes left in the period.
Kyle Taylor stuffed the puck in the lower right corner to knot it up 3:30 before intermission.
Plattsburgh continued to fire away at the Castleton net in the third, and eventually Mooney's slapshot found the twine. Vick Schlueter and Ryan Craig assisted.
The Spartans put just three shots on goal in the period.
"I think we ran out of gas," Castleton coach Alex Todd said. "It's sad to say, but unfortunately we didn't look like we had enough energy today to do it.
"And when you see a game like this, where as the game went along, we just seemed to get farther and farther behind, that's frustrating."
Cadieux turned away 17 shots for his second straight win.
Castleton's Brad Barber was sent off the ice in the middle of the first period after he hit Alex Jensen in the corner, leaving Jensen lying on the ice for a couple of minutes. Barber was assessed a 5-minute major for hitting from behind as well as a game misconduct.
The Cardinals couldn't score on the long power play and finished 0-for-5 with the man-advantage.
"
(The Spartans are) a good hockey team, and to be able to find a way to win is so important," Emery said. "Because a lot of times we outplay teams and we don't find a way to win — we find the opposite."
George Lotito and Tim Coffman tallied consecutive goals in the last four minutes of the second period to put No. 9 Utica (9-4) ahead in the consolation game.
Babson (3-9) had scored twice earlier in the second to take a 2-1 lead.
Ridge Garbutt netted two power-play goals in the third, and Trever Hertz added a short-handed marker as the Pioneers pulled away. Evan Smith earned the win by stopping 21 shots.
Jay Haseley and Matt Leer scored for the Beavers.
—
Consolation
Utica 6, Babson 2
Babson 0 2 0 — 2
Utica 1 2 3 — 6
First period- 1, U, Schmitt (Chlanda, Garbutt), 2:01. Penalties: Heavey, B (hitting after whistle), 6:54. Gaffney, U (hitting after whistle), 6:54. O'Neill, B (hooking), 10:08. Heavey, B (cross checking), 11:24.
Second period- 2, B, Haseley (Hoban), 1:14. 3, B, Leer (Bonazza, O'Neill), 9:17. 4, U, Lotito (Santiago, Schmitt), 16:03. 5, U, Coffman (Hertz, Chlanda), 19:59 (pp). Penalties: LaFosse, U (hooking), 7:06. Heavey, B (cross checking), 12:30. Carlson, B (interference), 19:29.
Third period- 6, U, Garbutt (Coffman), Zappia), 1:56 (pp). 7, U, Hertz, 5:39 (sh). 8, U, Garbutt (Chlanda, Hertz), 8:05 (pp).
Shots on goal:
Babson 9 9 14 — 32
Utica 8 9 6 — 23
Goaltending (shots-saves): Testa, B, 32-26. Smith, U, 23-21.
Power plays: (goals-opportunities): Babson 0-3; Utica 3-9.
Attendance: 348.
—
Championship
Plattsburgh State 2, Castleton 1
Castleton 0 1 0 — 1
Plattsburgh 0 1 1 — 2
First period- Penalties: Lesswing, C (high sticking), 6:33. Lesswing, C (interference), 9:44. Barber, C (hitting from behind), 10:20. Barber, C (game misconduct), 10:20. Kaye, PSU (interference), 16:27. Grace, PSU (tripping), 18:26.
Second period- 1, C, Zeggil (Lazorko), 11:00. 2, PSU, Taylor (N. Jensen, MacLeod), 16:30. Penalties: Wieland, C (interference), 7:23. Lesswing, C (interference), 13:57.
Third period- 3, PSU, Mooney (Schlueter, Craig), 14:52. Penalties: Zeggil, C (hooking), 0:42. Alonzo, C (cross checking), 19:42. N. Jensen, PSU (N. Jensen), 19:42.
Shots on goal:
Castleton 8 10 3 — 21
Plattsburgh 10 20 12 — 42
Goaltenders (shots-saves): Cinotti, C, 42-40. Cadieux, PSU, 21-20.
Power plays (goals-opportunities): Castleton 0-1; Plattsburgh 0-5.
Attendance: 1,668.
Email Courtney Lewis at:
clewis@pressrepublican.com