What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

PC Police: A New Low

The Rube

Retired Due To User Interface
This commercial angers me. The weight of the word in question is FAR from the other words used as examples. New low, as far as I'm concerned.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/T549VoLca_Q" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

I can't imagine why you would waste time ranting about this.

My guess is that to someone who is developmentally disabled, the "R" word is just as heavy.
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

I can't imagine why you would waste time ranting about this.

My guess is that to someone who is developmentally disabled, the "R" word is just as heavy.

Comparing to "n***er" really got to me. After reading the book of the same name, one should really see the difference. I'm not saying "retarded" is not bad, but no way does it carry the same weight. No way.
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

Comparing to "n***er" really got to me. After reading the book of the same name, one should really see the difference. I'm not saying "retarded" is not bad, but no way does it carry the same weight. No way.

In this case, I'm not sure it's worth getting undies in a bunch over semantics.

Again, to someone who is disabled, it probably carries the same weight.

Make your stand though if you feel the need.
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

Comparing to "n***er" really got to me. After reading the book of the same name, one should really see the difference. I'm not saying "retarded" is not bad, but no way does it carry the same weight. No way.

Especially as it started out purely as a technical, descriptive, non-judgmental diagnostic term. If you slow down a natural process, you "retard" its development. Some long-established practitioners still use the term in its old-fashioned technical diagnostic sense and don't quite understand what the fuss is about.

It is only after people starting using the word colloquially, outside of its original context, that some people got their knickers in a twist.

It doesn't matter much what neutral, non-judgmental, technical, diagnostic term is used to replace it in clinical work (practitioners need to use some term to describe the condition, no?); in 20 years the same thing will have happened to that term and we'll be doing this dance all over again.
 
Last edited:
Re: PC Police: A New Low

Especially as it started out purely as a technical, descriptive, non-judgmental diagnostic term.
So did the N word.

If this is what the reflexive anti-PC crowd is angry about, I'll pitch in with the oh so scary Statist PC Police.
 
Last edited:
Re: PC Police: A New Low

Between this and the recent billboards in Duluth, MN (http://unfaircampaign.org/) I'm sick of all this crap. This "PSA" was the final straw.
Gee...not too offensive. :rolleyes: "It's hard to see racism when you're white." Bullcrap it is.

Unfair? How about those ridiculous generalizations scribbled on her face? Possibly the worst campaign / propaganda for any cause I've ever seen.
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

If we're worrying this much about whether or not it's okay to say "retarded" and other such things, we've officially run out of serious problems as a society.
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

Especially as it started out purely as a technical, descriptive, non-judgmental diagnostic term. If you slow down a natural process, you "retard" its development. Some long-established practitioners still use the term in its old-fashioned technical diagnostic sense and don't quite understand what the fuss is about.

It is only after people starting using the word colloquially, outside of its original context, that some people got their knickers in a twist.

It doesn't matter much what neutral, non-judgmental, technical, diagnostic term is used to replace it in clinical work (practitioners need to use some term to describe the condition, no?); in 20 years the same thing will have happened to that term and we'll be doing this dance all over again.
Yep - it's referred to as a "euphemism treadmill."
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

Yep - it's referred to as a "euphemism treadmill."
In other words, stick your head in the sand when somebody co-opts a word as an insult, and don't respect the people who are offended by it?

Yeah, right, I'll remember that the next time somebody says "he was trying to jew me out of my change"? :rolleyes:

Don't dislocate your shoulder with these gyrations, folks. If something becomes hurtful, just stop using the freaking term. How hard is that? Does it really destroy your personal freedom not to call some poor kid a "retard"?

There is a point where "principle" is just another word for being a jerk.
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

In other words, stick your head in the sand when somebody co-opts a word as an insult, and don't respect the people who are offended by it?

Yeah, right, I'll remember that the next time somebody says "he was trying to jew me out of my change"? :rolleyes:

Don't dislocate your shoulder with these gyrations, folks. If something becomes hurtful, just stop using the freaking term. How hard is that? Does it really destroy your personal freedom not to call some poor kid a "retard"?

There is a point where "principle" is just another word for being a jerk.

It's a miracle. Yes sir, a gosh darn miracle!
 
Re: PC Police: A New Low

In other words, stick your head in the sand when somebody co-opts a word as an insult, and don't respect the people who are offended by it?

Yeah, right, I'll remember that the next time somebody says "he was trying to jew me out of my change"? :rolleyes:

Don't dislocate your shoulder with these gyrations, folks. If something becomes hurtful, just stop using the freaking term. How hard is that? Does it really destroy your personal freedom not to call some poor kid a "retard"?

There is a point where "principle" is just another word for being a jerk.
Hey now. I didn't advocate anything - I just pointed out that words' starting out neutral but then picking up enough negative connotation that they fall out of favor is a common enough phenomenon that there's actually a term for it. I made no value judgments whatsoever.

Completely agree with the bolded sentence above.
 
Back
Top