Re: Obama 7 - now what?
You're missing the point. Private lenders — not government-backed Fannie and Freddie — issued the vast majority of subprime loans. Fannie did not issue large amounts of non-traditional mortgages relative to the private sector. Something like 80% of subprime loans in 2006 were made by financial institutions not governed by the CRA. In fact CRA loans date back to the late 70's well before the collapse began and it was the Bush administration’s weakening of the CRA which coincided with the subprime boom. And the banks mostly responsible for issuing these loans did not do so to meet CRA obligations, they did so to make money.
If I'm not mistaken, CRA and banking regulation was weakened under Clinton near the end of his term.
That aside, it was the expansion of Fannie/Freddie loan qualifications that drove the banks further to the fringes of qualified borrowers. You can argue that the lenders didn't have to make those loans, but between having the expansion of government-backed lending on pushing on one side, and then having groups like ACORN pulling lenders on other, bad things were going to--and did--happen. The FHA is getting killed right now because the number of bad loans they are backing is going through the roof. The subprime mortgage market started the fuse.....but if that were the only problem, then why were Fannie/Freddie going under last year? Answer: They loosened their criteria and took on borrowers that were not qualified.
And for clarification: There is no such thing as a "CRA loan". There are loans that are made that fall under the classification of lending in a CRA-qualified area, but there is no "CRA Loan Program". Visit the US Bank on 20th West and Superior St. in Duluth. The Lincoln Park/West End neighborhood is a dump.....ask UMDBHIK--he lives there.
There is little reason for that bank to be there, other than to pad US Bank's resume with regards to the CRA. The bank loses money hand over fist operating out there, even with the skeleton crew they have running it. Believe me, they don't approve loans there just to "make money". Everyone has to qualify just the same.
You're also yelping at the wrong bunch. If it was the non-CRA regulated lenders making the bad loans, then why are you chirping at banks? The vast majority of mortgage-lending banks are governed by the CRA.
Read up on the Federal Housing Finance Reform Acts of 2005 and 2007.
Neither of those bills ever became law, smart guy:
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h110-1427
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h109-1461
And on top of that, ACORN was a major supporter of the 2007 version.....sponsored by.....wait for it......Barney Frank. Which is nice:
http://www.naca.net/_assets/shared/633154392959218750.pdf