Comley really wanted Renfrew, but couldn't get past him being off the bench for so long. I'm interested to eventually find out if he was offered first, which would not be a surprise.
Shyiak still felt slighted from the search that produced Potulny. If it was any other AD, I doubt he would have put himself back in the mix. Now let's see who he can assemble as a staff. Why not ask Renfrew if he wants to be the associate HC? They were on staff together for a year in 2001-02.
Whitten is the lowest paid head coach in D1 college hockey, and possibly in ANY D1 sport. He would have more than doubled his salary and seen a big jump in resources. But unless there was no other option, I doubt that Comley would have essentially dealt a death blow to his alma mater by poaching their coach so late.