Re: Nescac 2009/2010
great win for Williams no doubt, Tuesday will be interesting. I'm sorry there are a couple of teams in the conference who have coaches that won't win no matter who they have, they play the wrong players, panic during crunch time, point fingers when things go wrong and can't inspire young men. I'm going with Middlebury.
From following your posts over the past couple of seasons, I'm assuming that the two coaches you're referring to as uninspiring are Bill Kangas (Williams) and Terry Meagher (Bowdoin). I don't know Kangas, and don't follow Williams hockey closely enough to have an opinion about him. You may well be right about the situation at Williams. Nevertheless, I know Meagher personally and have followed the Bowdoin program for four decades now, as a student and alumnus, and as such I can't agree with your contempt for a man whom I believe has been one of the premier coaches in Division III for almost three decades. His winning percentage (.665) compares well with Middlebury's Bill Beaney (.709), who has arguably set the standard for success as a Division III coach.
Before Middlebury had its two amazing runs of national titles, there was Bowdoin, finishing the 1985-86 season ranked as the number one team in the country but unable to play in the national tournament due to arcane NESCAC rules. There was also Bowdoin losing the ECAC championship games in 1988 and 1989 to Merrimack teams ready to move to Division I (and, in fact, the 1989 Merrimack team was invited to and played in two rounds of the Division I NCAA tournament). Despite the eventual loss, the Polar Bears led for a good part, if not most, of the 1989 championship team. It's hard to fault Meagher for not beating a team that was a "de facto" Division I team. It was sad, moreover, that those two outstanding Bowdoin teams were not allowed to compete in the national tournament against other true Division III teams. In 1993 Bowdoin became the first team to win an ECAC Division III title as the eighth seed. Again, no national tournament participation was possible. I lament that there haven't been any championships for the past seventeen years, but Bowdoin has been a contender in the late 1990s and through most of the past decade though the talent level hasn't been as consistently high as at Middlebury and Norwich. More recently, I believe that it'd be rather simplistic to atribute Bowdoin's loss to Middlebury in the 2007 NESCAC championship game, when Bowdoin had arguably the most talented squad in the league, to poor coaching. Despite losing to Bowdoin 6-2 in the regular season, that Middlebury team had enough talent and experience to take a game from anyone in the league, and possibly in the country. After squeaking by Colby in the NESCAC semifinals, the Panthers played a near-perfect game against the Polar Bears in the finals. Middlebury went on to represent NESCAC magnificently in the Division III national tournament, and was denied a ninth NCAA championship in a heartbreaking overtime loss to Oswego.
I will be happy to talk to you privately about the Bowdoin program and Terry Meagher by email or phone at any time.
As to the Williams-Middlebury game, it should be a beauty. I'm hoping for a tie...
