Re: Minnesota Golden Gophers 2009-2010 the last year of the old WCHA
A few thoughts come to mind with the news of Sam Lofquist leaving the team and withdrawing from the UMN:
1) I think current adjustments to the CBA and subsequent recruiting strategies to recruit much younger players will at times result in this type of negative outcome. Lofquist accelerated his HS educ., with honors no less, to come to the Gophers. Sam is a national merit scholar. However, the psychological level of players like Lofquist, compared to those who have spent more time and matured in the USHL, will be different and comparatively less developed. Egotistical motives, multiple options, family pressures (strong sports family) and an uncertain future can lead a young player to make sudden life changing decisions regardless of previous committments (i.e. Jim O'Brien).
Personally I get tired of watching bright students like this quit college to chase an NHL dream, which in Lofquist's case may be fairly remote. Most athletes like this end up in a hockey career of mediocrity with no educational support to fall back on.
2) It's very possible that Lofquist being a healthy scratch last weekend in his home state of Wisconsin was disappointing. However, I'm sure his unfulfilled expectations and subsequent decision to move on was processed over time with regard to other factors as well.
3) Symbolically, another player leaving during the season unfortunately sends another negative signal of coaching incompetency to the general public and fanbase especially at a vulnerable time when team play is below expectations. It resurfaces past criticisms of Lucia's recruiting policies and his abilities to generate appropriate levels of team chemistry and productivity that meet the traditional expectations of the fanbase and boosters. Regardless of whether the criticism has merit or not, this is perhaps the most serious repercussion of Lofquist's departure.
4) Obviously, the loss of Lofquist will not have a tremendous effect on the overall talent of the Gophers. However, it remains to be seen what effect it will have on team unity and chemistry. There are several variables that are uncertain here.
I listened to the Don Lucia radio program tonight and there was no mention of it. The coaching staff concluding that it was not appropriate at this time to release that information indicates that the situation is still in process.
EDIT:
IMO this situation helps illustrate again of how the values of college athletes today are in a state of accelerated change like never before. Professional sports and it's values, along with university fiscal and enrollment policies, continue to influence and contribute to the growing chasm between scholarship and athletics. We also have the unfortunate privilege of witnessing the gradual death of every remaining vestige of the amateur spirit within the growing divide of professional collegiate athletics and community.