I think Whitehead has gotten serious mileage out of his last few FF appearances in 04, 06 and 07, especially these last two. While he did validate the 2004 season with a HE title and a win vs BC in the FF, the 06 and 07 stuff is misrepresented IMO. Timmay really still is benefitting from the nice draws in 2006 and 2007, staying East and getting Harvard and St. Cloud in the first rounds and even getting 4th seed Umass in the 2nd round in 2007 (thanks Clarkson... ECAC!). The 2007 Maine squad was a 5th place HE team that got swept at UMA in round 1 of the HE tourney as well. And yet they were booking a trip to STL for a Frozen Four appearance.
Perhaps the worst is the contract extension after the moral HE title victory over BC in 2010. That team finished 2 games over .500 and didn't make the NCAAs but of course they got to the HE title game via a narrow 3-game best of win at Alfond over Lowell (game 3 was an OT winner) and a win over BU (1 game over .500) before losing to BC in overtime at the Garden.
The problem is though, if they would have gotten rid of Timmy who would've been the coach? The grass isn't always greener, and can any Maine fan honestly say they would have been comfortable with Blake James making the hire?
Maine had an incredibly easy draw in 2007 but not 2006. Most people actually picked Harvard to beat them. Both the 2006 amd 2007 teams had quite a bit of talent but neither did as much as they could have during the regular season.