Re: For ECAC Fans: Where Should Our Tournament Be Held?
I kind of like the idea of having it hosted by each school (not a fan of the "first place in the conference" thing though; it would pretty much rotate between a very small number of schools). This would unfortunately mean each school only gets to host once every 12 years, but I think the idea itself is cool. Meehan Auditorium at Brown, for example, is set up so there are two identical sides with standing room above each net (I believe Union's Messa Rink has a similar setup). This would create very distinct and unified fan sections, which would make for an intense atmosphere. The size of the rink (2,495-3,100, depending on who you ask) would also guarantee a packed house, as I'm sure even AC gets enough fans to fill a rink of that size.
Though I'm not as familiar with most of the other rinks, I'm sure it would be equally neat for each school to host the finals. They could promote the heck out of it, drive up ticket demand, make a nice little profit (to be shared with the league, of course), and get a buzz going on campus, even if their team wasn't participating (and if Brown hosted, we most likely would not be involved
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e8e8f/e8e8f10ee7969490cfdc1dc1612ff37bbd0ae6f5" alt="Stick out tongue :p :p"
).
A problem I could see, however, would be finding a way to ensure that the seats are sold to fans of the teams who are actually involved. I'm sure at Lynah or Ingalls, the tickets would be gobbled up by Cornell and Yale season ticket-holders immediately. Obviously at places with either larger capacities (RPI, Dartmouth) or smaller fanbases (Brown, Harvard, Princeton, Colgate) this wouldn't be a problem, but it would be lame to see Lynah Rink filled with 3,000 Big Red fans watching in total apathy (assuming Cornell didn't make it that year) with only several hundred people who actually care dispersed throughout the arena. I don't know if anyone follows MLS (probably not), but in the 2009 MLS Cup, Seattle hosted the final between Los Angeles and Real Salt Lake, and while it sold out, it had to be 90% Seattle fans who really didn't care about the outcome of the game.
In reality, each school hosting the finals would probably not work out, but it's a cool thing to think about. Each school would get to show off a bit, even if they weren't participating in the event they'd be hosting.