Re: Elmira College - 2012/2013
I guess I wonder about this tradition theory, they have never won the national title. They aren't a powerhouse like a Middlebury.
No national championships, but a strong history of conference championships. 10 ECAC-W Championships, 5 runner-ups in the conference tournament.
As PSUChamps noted, they're also one of the teams that have qualified for the most NCAA tournaments (caveat: Middlebury wasn't eligible until 1994, due to conference rules. So their number is probable artificially low). Runner-up in the 1988 NCAA DIII championship, on top of a runner-up performance in DII before the establishment of DIII hockey, losing to Mankato State.
An all-time record of 670-325-42 since the team was founded in 1973 is nothing to shake a stick at. Their 2011-2012 media guide lists 79 first-team, second-team, and all-rookie team awards given to Elmira Players by the ECAC-W conference since 1987. It lists 49 players who scored at least 100 points in their 4-year careers. 16 players named NCAA All-Americans. 13 former players coaching/administrating at the NCAA (DI and DIII), USA Hockey, and NHL levels. One of those was even an assistant for the Blackhawks when they won the cup!
We're also talking about the school where everything - from hand soap and trashcans to john deer sidewalk snowplows - is purple and gold. A school so focused on traditions that it has its school colors, a school flower, and even a school shape (the octagon).
Does Elmira Hockey have a tradition of winning national championships? On the women's side yes, but on the men's side, no. But they have tradition. A tradition of always being competitive on the national stage. That's the kind of tradition that attracts recruits. With a team with that kind of history, what hard-working, driven, college-age DIII-calibre hockey player WOULDN'T enjoy the opportunity to try to be a part of the class that finally puts Elmira Men's Hockey over the edge, lifting the national championship trophy?
Also, in response to your specific statement that they're "not a powerhouse like Middlebury"... I'm pretty sure I watched Elmira beat Middlebury at Chip Kenyon Arena last season... so... yeah.
