Re: Elections 2012: You must choose the lesser of two weevils
These guys aren't capitalists, Fresh, they're just predators. They don't make anything anybody wants. They just gamble with other people's lives. They're scum.
Funny thing to say, coming from someone who defends evolution by natural selection against creationsim elsewhere...and I thought you knew something about statistics as well!
When people support positions I support yet use dopey reasons I challenge them, because I don't want their nonsense to pollute the receptivity others might have for "my" positions if they hear the "dopey" reasons first and close their minds, so that their minds become inaccessible to better reasoning afterward.
Pretend for a minute you are running a cancer treatment center. People who already have cancer in the first place are the only ones who come to you. Some of them die. Shall we excoriate you for the heartless way you take people's money to provide treatment, yet the treatment failed? or do we look at the additional longevity you provide these people, even though they did die, do we look at the palliative care you provided, do we look at those people who did respond to treatment and now have cancer in remission? how would you evaluate a cancer treatment center anyway?
Private equity isn't much different. Private equity firms select companies that are already in trouble, and try to turn them around. If the company wasn't in trouble to begin with, they wouldn't be in play. Some of these companies fail anyway; yet many of them either remain in business longer than they otherwise would have, or they completely succeed. The ones that remain in business longer than they would have otherwise, generally provide a transition period for the employees to find work elsewhere that they would not have had otherwise.
Statistically, then, the "deck is stacked" against the private equity firm....they do not start with any old regular company, they start with troubled companies, and no one is 100% successful all the time. A steel company failed? how shocking....a textile firm failed....really? name one US-based textile firm that survived. It's easy to cherry-pick the extreme outliers and pile on. How about a balanced assessment across the entire portfolio? Sorry, it doesn't fit our political agenda, and so we'll merely take the most egregious failure and pretend that it's representative, while the other side will take the most spectacular success and pretend that
it is representative, and we'll merely reinforce our existing beliefs and learn nothing useful whatsoever when it comes to policy prescriptions.
It's not only the companies that are "turned around" by private equity that save or create jobs, it also is all the additional incremental jobs in the supply chain and the shipping companies as well. Staples alone created hundreds of thousands of incremental extra jobs, yet we won't hear much about that.
So, sorry, your judgment that these people are scum carries about as much weight as it would if you were ranting about all the cancer deaths that occur at a cancer treatment center. You can be morally outraged over superficial, deliberately slanted statistics while knowing little about the overall picture.