D1 Commitments 2011-2012

[capitalist]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

So what I understand is Thoroughbreds who have a very good team this year led by Stephanie Anderson (U18 and committed to MN) needed a top goalie and that Turner was highly regarded. The JWHL will be a great place for her to take her game to the next level and prepare for D1 level of play in her home town. Here is current roster

http://mnthoroughbreds.com/players.htm

Hey, I'm just saying 3 hours is a long way to drive one way for practice 4 times a week. The beauty of Minnesota hockey is that we don't have to spend hours in a car daily like they do in other areas of the country. The T'Breds have had players from St. Cloud and Rochester and of course all over Western Wisconsin in recent years, but Duluth is a whole different level of travel than those places.

You say they 'needed a top goalie'. Are you saying that they recruited her? I don't think they really do that. There are enough HS fans, etc, who dislike the idea of the program without the T'Breds giving them good reason to.

 

[WCHFan]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

In many states players drive 3+ hours to play hockey. Who cares as long as it works for girls.

 

[brookyone]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

There are enough HS fans, etc, who dislike the idea of the program without the T'Breds giving them good reason to.

What good reason would anyone in Minnesota have to dislike the T'breds program and the opportunity it offers to it's players?

 

[capitalist]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

What good reason would anyone in Minnesota have to dislike the T'breds program and the opportunity it offers to it's players?

Recruiting players away from their HS programs. You can decide for yourself what the meaning of 'good' is.
I assume you're playing devil's advocate, and I ain't falling into the trap of getting into it on this forum. I've said too much already.

 

[capitalist]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

In many states players drive 3+ hours to play hockey. Who cares as long as it works for girls.

I have a hard time believing that it "works" for anybody. It might be barely tolerable, or build character as an obstacle to overcome, or looking back you might say, "Well it was worth it". But having a teenager spend 6 hours a day in a car? How does that "work"?

 

[brookyone]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

Recruiting players away from their HS programs. You can decide for yourself what the meaning of 'good' is.
I assume you're playing devil's advocate, and I ain't falling into the trap of getting into it on this forum. I've said too much already.

Nope...I asked the question simply because I couldn't think of a reason anyone would dislike the T'breds program.

Yeah, I think that's a players decision entirely though, so I wouldn't consider that a good reason myself. I really can't find fault with anyone if an opportunity is there, it's offered and the player wants to take advantage.

 

[brookyone]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

I have a hard time believing that it "works" for anybody. It might be barely tolerable, or build character as an obstacle to overcome, or looking back you might say, "Well it was worth it". But having a teenager spend 6 hours a day in a car? How does that "work"?

Wish I could dig up an old story on former Gopher Kelly Stephens. It documented this very set of circumstances regarding long commutes to play at a level not available to her locally, and how it did ultimately work for her, benefiting her and definitely helping her achieve her division I and subsequently her Olympic aspirations and success.

Doesn't mean it would work for everyone. I imagine some, maybe many just wouldn't make the sacrifices.

 

[notfromaroundhere]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

I have a hard time believing that it "works" for anybody. It might be barely tolerable, or build character as an obstacle to overcome, or looking back you might say, "Well it was worth it". But having a teenager spend 6 hours a day in a car? How does that "work"?

Been there done that. And more than 6 hours in a day. And at the 12U and 14U levels. Worth it. You bet! And never used road legs as an excuse.

 

[D2D]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

I have a hard time believing that it "works" for anybody. It might be barely tolerable, or build character as an obstacle to overcome, or looking back you might say, "Well it was worth it". But having a teenager spend 6 hours a day in a car? How does that "work"?

I agree that it's a long commute, but maybe she's arranged some housing in the Twin Cities so she won't have to travel so much? And even if she hasn't, it's entirely her decision. The beauty of it is that she had an option, and she chose what she thought would be the best for her.

 

[5 4 Fighting]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

I heard there was a 13 yr. old left winger down around that Mankato country that somebody had better sign ...and quick.

 

[OnMAA]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

Been there done that. And more than 6 hours in a day. And at the 12U and 14U levels. Worth it. You bet! And never used road legs as an excuse.

Know of one person who outfitted their family van with a bed in the back for the rides home after games/practices. Two to three hour rides are not unheard of in some parts of the country. If you live rural, it is part of the equation, specially up here were winter can play havoc with the roads.

Our kids did much of their homework in the car/van over the years. It was actually an efficient use of their time. The oldest asked me to drive her, even after she had her licence, so she could do home work to and from the rink. She is now working her way into med school.

 

[Hockeydad4two]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

Our 1.5 hour trip taught our daughter time management skills. She got home from school and got what homework she could done. What was left, went with us in the van. We always had a book light in the glove compartment so she could read once it got dark.

She's now trying to make her third appearance on the all academic list while getting an engineering degree.

 

[Trillium]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

Been there done that. And more than 6 hours in a day. And at the 12U and 14U levels. Worth it. You bet! And never used road legs as an excuse.

Never did 6 hrs a day, but probably 3 hours total x 3-4 times per week for several years. Hated doing it at the time, and often wondered if it was worth it, especially when there were other good programs closer to home.

However, looking back on it, I'm so glad to have done it.

Teenagers (and certainly mine) are notorious for not wanting to talk to their parents. Most of the time questions are generally answered with barely a grunt if you're lucky. Pretty much the only meaningful, important and deep conversations I had with my kids happened on those car rides, and did so frequently. Without them, I doubt they ever would have happened at all.

So now I think those long car rides were priceless. Wouldn't trade them for anything.

 

[DC78-82]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

So now I think those long car rides were priceless. Wouldn't trade them for anything.

Better hold that thought for the next few years, because your rides to games are considerably longer now, and without the benefit of your D's conversations

 

[THE Icemom]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

We didn't have a 3 hr drive, but I usually had to get my son to practice at one rink(half an hour away), take my daughter to another rink (20 minutes beyond, all the time doing homework in the car, then pick up my son who then did homework until my daughter was done. My daughter went onto play DIII and was Dean's List, All Academic team and graduated early. If you want to juggle hockey and school, you have to find those snippits of time during the day to get the studying done. It is a "learned time management" skill that they will carry with them throughout their lives. I wish I had thought of the book light...I used to have to leave the dome light on in my car for my kids.

 

[OnMAA]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

Never did 6 hrs a day, but probably 3 hours total x 3-4 times per week for several years.....
...... now I think those long car rides were priceless. Wouldn't trade them for anything.

Better hold that thought for the next few years, because your rides to games are considerably longer now, and without the benefit of your D's conversations

Look at it on the positive side. Now you get to talk to your spouse for six plus hours, and once you get there, expect a big hug from the D.

P.S.....It's amazing how much they change between 1st year and 4th year. I loved the long car rides to and from the college games over the last three years, and looking forward to more of the same.

 

[MICZamboni]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

Also:

Amanda Makela.......G....Thunderbay.....ON
Jenna Dingeldien.....F.....Missisauga.....ON
Vaila Higson.....D......Edge School.....AB
Carolyne Lucznk.....D....Aeros.......ON
Hailey Brown......F.....Missisauga....ON
Shelby Bram
Kristine Grenier

Anyone have any thoughts on these players? Anyone see them play?

 

[OnMAA]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

Anyone have any thoughts on these players? Anyone see them play?

Makela is a prime time goalie. Backstopped her team to a national championship at U17 last year. She was on the TC U18 team that played in the series vs the US in LP.

Dingeldein is a big and strong forward with great size and strength. She played on Ontario Blue last year, and is a top player on a top team (Missy) this year. She should be able to step in and play right away. If she adds another gear to her game she would be really really good.

 

[D2D]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

The latest committment announced on the MN High School forum, to Bemidji State:

Alex Citrowske............D............Prior Lake High School................Prior Lake, MN

 

[wild77]

Re: D1 Commitments 2011-2012

The latest committment announced on the MN High School forum, to Bemidji State:

Alex Citrowske............D............Prior Lake High School................Prior Lake, MN

She has been a forward. Not sure why she is listed as a "D".