What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

Vanessa Marquez, an actress best known for her role as a nurse on “ER,” was shot and killed by South Pasadena police on Thursday, authorities confirmed on Friday.

Officers were called to Marquez’s home in the 1100 block of Fremont Avenue by a landlord to check on her welfare. When the officers arrived around 12 p.m., she was suffering from seizures and appeared unable to take care of herself. Officers called out paramedics and a mental health clinician, and continued to talk with her. After about 90 minutes, Marquez, 49, armed herself with a BB gun and pointed it at the officers, causing them to open fire, said Sheriff’s Lt. Joe Mendoza.

https://variety.com/2018/tv/news/vanessa-marquez-er-shot-killed-police-1202923337/
 
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

Someone who was seizing and yet they couldn't gain control of the situation ... in 90 minutes?
 
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

Is it true that standard practice for officers that if you have to shoot you shoot to kill?
 
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

Is it true that standard practice for officers that if you have to shoot you shoot to kill?

The polite phrase law enforcement trainers use is "aim for center of mass". In your center of mass are things like a heart, lungs, yadda-yadda.

And as I've said before, most cops spend less time on the fire range than I do (and I'm far from hardcore, maybe 90 minutes a month). And when you look at law enforcement shooting stats*, their accuracy isn't that great. They're aiming center of mass as much to not miss as for the stopping power.


*This book has some good, or is it bad, NYPD accuracy numbers on and off range. Hint: there are single digit percentage numbers in the accuracy data.
 
Last edited:
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

Is it true that standard practice for officers that if you have to shoot you shoot to kill?

That is false. You shoot to not miss. Happens to be the torso, where all the important things are.

To be snarky, blame God, he put those things in the torso. ;)
 
That is false. You shoot to not miss. Happens to be the torso, where all the important things are.

To be snarky, blame God, he put those things in the torso. ;)

That is also false. Cops are trained to "stop the threat." They are also trained that the best way to "stop the threat" is to deprive the brain of oxygen by shooting holes in the organs responsible for getting blood to the brain. But they definitely aren't trained to shoot to kill. :rolleyes:

http://prosecutor.cuyahogacounty.us...rawford-Review of Deadly Force-Tamir Rice.pdf (PDF). Applicable language is in the second to last paragraph.
 
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

If someone is unpredictable, officers are trained to step back (or take total control of the situation, which we have learned ends badly in current times). There are times where someone is so unhinged, nothing can really be done. It's sad, truly a tragedy, I am serious in saying this. Unfortunately, when someone (apparently) this unhinged points a weapon, the decision has been made. The individual will be shot.
 
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

That is also false. Cops are trained to "stop the threat." They are also trained that the best way to "stop the threat" is to deprive the brain of oxygen by shooting holes in the organs responsible for getting blood to the brain. But they definitely aren't trained to shoot to kill. :rolleyes:

http://prosecutor.cuyahogacounty.us...rawford-Review of Deadly Force-Tamir Rice.pdf (PDF). Applicable language is in the second to last paragraph.
What in the actual f? Whoever wrote this piece is talking pure bullsh*. You stop the threat by shooting the largest "bullseye" of said threat. Period. Nothing more. Yes, it's the torso. Yes, the torso contains vital organs. That is not the officer's fault. S/he may hit the gut, may hit the upper right shoulder area, may hit the heart. The only thing that report has right is shooting for the hand that has the gun/etc. AKA "sharpshooting."
 
What in the actual f? Whoever wrote this piece is talking pure bullsh*. You stop the threat by shooting the largest "bullseye" of said threat. Period. Nothing more. Yes, it's the torso. Yes, the torso contains vital organs. That is not the officer's fault. S/he may hit the gut, may hit the upper right shoulder area, may hit the heart. The only thing that report has right is shooting for the hand that has the gun/etc. AKA "sharpshooting."

The person who wrote that is a retired supervising special agent with the FBI's training unit. She was one of the experts brought in to assess the Tamir Rice shooting in Cleveland. Shockingly, she sided with the cop.
 
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

The person who wrote that is a retired supervising special agent with the FBI's training unit. She was one of the experts brought in to assess the Tamir Rice shooting in Cleveland. Shockingly, she sided with the cop.

She's part of the problem, then. As I have mentioned many times, I have relatives that have served the force. That was never part of their training. Ever. You simply want to stop the threat. You shoot at the greatest mass, period. Nothing more than that.
 
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

I've always heard center mass from the law enforcement guys I knew in college. My cousin had also said that's what he was trained to do. He stated "If your dead on you'll probably hit them in the liver or stomach."

Still not great, but not necessarily fatal.
 
Re: Cops 5: Barney Fife, Now in Real Life!

I think once the shooting starts -- from either the cops or the other guys -- it becomes less of a question as to what they are shooting at. Once the shots start flying you have to EXPECT there will be fatalities. It is an exercise in futility to argue over things like center mass and depriving vital organs of oxygen. I think most reasonable people realize that cops are trained to "shoot to stop" and that parsing that down to its technical details is pointless. As Sic pointed out he sometimes spends 90 minutes a month at a range -- more than most cops -- and those 90 minutes are entirely without the mental strain that is present when cops are reasonably fearful for their safety or the safety of other innocent people. In the heat of battle expecting even a highly proficient officer to hit someone in the wrist so they can't hold their gun anymore is ridiculous and I'm sure most of us here know that.

The real issue is simply the cops are firing at times today that perhaps 30 or 40 or more years ago they weren't (despite the fact that law enforcement is leaps and bounds safer in 2018 than it was 30 or 40 or more years ago -- and I've posted many, many times the empirical data that proves this). We're not hiring the right people to be cops, and we're not holding the wrong ones accountable at an acceptable level when they do discharge a firearm. Once we start seeing reams of black cops shooting unarmed white guys you might be able to also persuade me it is a training problem.

Remember that in the case that unofan linked that report to, the officer had previously served in a suburban department and his chief there thought he was an inept officer, thought that he didn't possess the mental maturity to be a cop, and routinely failed to display a proficient use of his firearm. He had no more business being a cop than I would have being a brain surgeon. Without even getting into any of the issues surrounding the races of the participants or bigotry or profiling, had the CPD simply not hired an individual who should never have been given a badge and allowed to carry a gun, the young man Tamir Rice would almost certainly still be alive. That is the real issue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top