Re: All Things Denver, XXVIII
Now that Chevy's gone, how would you all rank these 4 DU goalies from recent years: Dubie, Berkhoel, Mannino and Cheverie? My non-statistical analysis would put them in this order:
1) Dubie
2) Manno
3) Berkhoel
4) Chevy
It's weird to have Chevy at the bottom of this list. But Berkhoel and Manno came through big-time for DU when it counted the most. Dubie didn't win a title, but I just remember him as such a dominant and consistent goalie that I can't put Manno above him.
It really depends what you value most.
Dubie probably had the best four year career and was a second team all-American who turned down the NHL to return as a senior, but did not win the big prize.
Manno won the big NCAA prize as a freshman, and had a strong DU career, but was never an All-American.
Berkhoel won the big NCAA prize as a senior and was a standout when DU needed down the strretch that year but was up and down otherwise, and was also not an All-American.
Chevy started slowly at DU, but was a first team All-American as a junior and was a serious Hobey candidate until the end, when he was unable to carry the Pioneers to NCAA success.
One other thing to consider is the platooning nature of DU's goaltenders. Most seasons, DU has two goalies that split time 50/50 or 2/3rds-1/3 or so. Only Mannino and Chevy had a single season where they played most of the games. Dubie and Berkhoel were always platooned.
If you value overall stats, it's probably Dubie or Chevy.
If you value NCAA Hardware, it's either Manno or Berkhoel.
If you value All-American status, it's Chevy.
If you value four year careers, it's Dubie.