Re: 2009-2010 Official Vermont Season Thread
Wow, you really are missing some chromosomes there jcarter.
While I can appreciate your desire to put the most weight on the poll that fits your ability to counter my logical arguments and defend Yale at all costs (which is right up there with grantfan's defense of AFA as a good team because they defend our country), the polls also are not set in stone and will also change as the season progresses. They are both fluid as the results affect them. One is by math and one is by people's opinion. While I like trusting my own opinion over math in a lot of cases, the major fault with any human poll is the preseason bias and how the results affect them. The human nature of the pollsters is not to rank them each week but to move teams up and down based on results. Early on, say, Dec 10th, the polls are still influenced too much by the preseason bias. Mathematical formulas have no such bias.
You can argue with yourself until you get red in the face, but we all know that the poll you know and love so much right now means ZERO when it comes time to pick the teams in the NCAA selection process. They use things like RPI, H2H, COP, TUC and others to compare teams and create a ranking model. BC is far superior to Yale in many of these things right now (most notable the heavily weighted RPI) and as a result has a higher PWR (aside from being a vastly superior team on the ice). You can bet a lot of the teams near the top of the PWR right now will be up near the top at the end of the year as well (Bemidji, BC, Miami, Denver as a few examples). Barring disasters they are in the NCAAs and with a good record the rest of the way they are higher seeded teams if not 1 seeds.