What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

Status
Not open for further replies.
I caught about 10-15 minutes of the game last night on a free stream...

Caufield is a sniper but nowhere near the level of an Oshie or Toews in that he plays so selfishly and one dimensional it’s difficult to fathom his game translating to the NHL.

Miller makes so many dumb passes I almost wonder how he was a 1st rounder.

I’ve come around on Achan, make him the Captain next season.

Turcotte disappears for stretches as does Dhoogie and the defense overall leave the goalies hung to dry far too often.

As far as selfish play from the one and dones they make Zent, Schier, Moore, Tucker, Fairchild, MacDonald et al look like the 90 team by comparison to today’s.
Comparing Caufield to Toews is like comparing Turcotte to Ovechkin. It’s just weird.

I did lol @ the Achan comment. Gotta think that conversation is what made the title of this thread. All in good fun, of course.
 
Comparing Caufield to Toews is like comparing Turcotte to Ovechkin. It’s just weird.

I did lol @ the Achan comment. Gotta think that conversation is what made the title of this thread. All in good fun, of course.

😀

How did the refs and the tv crew miss Kalynuk getting roughed when he reached down to grab his stick?
 
Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

So we take a stupid cross checking penalty to give them 5-3 and a goal They just don’t learn.

I’m only listening, and haven’t watched how the game is unfolding but unless they have a miraculous third period their massive two game winning streak is snapped.
 
Re: Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

And that’s the game. I’ve seen more than enough from this coaching staff and the one and dones. Miller can leave too, the team will be better without him.
 
And that’s the game. I’ve seen more than enough from this coaching staff and the one and dones. Miller can leave too, the team will be better without him.
0

One and dones aren't looking so one and done-ish at this point. Will NHL teams wants these guys next year? Its gonna be funny to see what happens next year if no one leaves early and they have 73 guys on the roster.

Then Granato will say he finally has the pieces in place. And he'll conveniently forget all the crap he said about this being the year.

Here's a thought: How about you just get better every year and improve a little with all the resources you have at the UW?

Cole at MSU is in his 3rd season and went from last place to 1st (as of now).

Granato is in his 4th season and went from second to last (as of now).
 
0

One and dones aren't looking so one and done-ish at this point. Will NHL teams wants these guys next year? Its gonna be funny to see what happens next year if no one leaves early and they have 73 guys on the roster.

Then Granato will say he finally has the pieces in place. And he'll conveniently forget all the crap he said about this being the year.

Here's a thought: How about you just get better every year and improve a little with all the resources you have at the UW?

Cole at MSU is in his 3rd season and went from last place to 1st (as of now).

Granato is in his 4th season and went from second to last (as of now).

Excellent points!

I thought of that too, what if the NHL clubs tell these kids they need more seasoning? Where do the incoming players go?
 
Re: Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

One and dones aren't looking so one and done-ish at this point. Will NHL teams wants these guys next year? Its gonna be funny to see what happens next year if no one leaves early and they have 73 guys on the roster.

Is it not mind blowing that there are thoughts that say it would be good that the one and does leave? What bizzarro are we living in? 6 months ago we were hoping to have maybe one of the 3 stay for a 2nd year. Holloway is the most complete of the 3 from what I have seen.

Maybe NHL teams will be like "*** is happening to our players at WI" and they essentially pull them. How much to these NHL GM's trust TG?
 
Is it not mind blowing that there are thoughts that say it would be good that the one and does leave? What bizzarro are we living in? 6 months ago we were hoping to have maybe one of the 3 stay for a 2nd year. Holloway is the most complete of the 3 from what I have seen.

Maybe NHL teams will be like "*** is happening to our players at WI" and they essentially pull them. How much to these NHL GM's trust TG?

Exactly. They've got to see their crowning jewels ****ing the dog under this staff and say, "**** Wisconsin. Send him to the CHL and get his mojo back. He's not learning anything there."
 
Re: Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

I don't know how this staff can remain the same next year. There will have to be changes. I'm not sure what that looks like but this B$ is unacceptable......
 
Re: Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

I thought, over all, the boys played much better this weekend. The biggest thing I noticed was they were hard in front of the opposing net. Traffic there constantly and guys not just out on drive by's, but stopping and battling for space and the puck. It was nice to see. Maybe Stroby's "Come to Jesus" talk with the F's last Saturday finally gained some traction. Outside of the penalties they were a much better team this weekend.

I thought the penalty situation yesterday was a lack of discipline at times, but also the ref's were terrible in their consistency. A ref can whistle something nearly every trip down the ice, but they are supposed to use discretion and keep the game fair and under control, not determine the outcome. I agree with Tony saying he doesn't know what to expect from officiating night to night in the B1G. There's just no consistency game to game or even play to play. By this point in the season you should be able to have an idea what they're going to call and what they're not. I have no idea, it's different every day.

On the 1st rounders: Caufield can play in the NHL right now. His total game isn't consistent enough yet or developed enough yet, but there are only a handful of guys in the world that can shoot the puck the way he can, and that's enough to get on the NHL ice. If he stays it's because of his teammates, or out of a desire to mature physically a bit more, but I don't think it will be because he doesn't have a roster spot to start the year.

Turcotte's Dad (Alfie) went up too soon and his NHL career never really got going. I don't think Alex will be in a hurry if there's some question about his game being ready, and right now he doesn't look ready. Another year would be a huge benefit to him long term.

Miller has the ability to go to the show, it just depends on how his season finishes. He could get going and dominate or he could just continue playing how he has been. It's not unusual at all for 1st round D to play 3 or 4 years NCAA, in fact it's unusual for them to play less than that. I think both he and Alex return.

Kalynuk could go pro, and probably should, as I think he has a game that's better suited to pro hockey.

I don't think that any NHL staff is worried at all about leaving their guys here to develop. They are playing the toughest schedule in NCAA and getting premier training. It's a great place for them to be.

Season has been frustrating to no end. I noticed though that if you flip just 3 losses to wins you can get the Badgers to #6 PWR right now. That's kind of crazy.
 
Re: Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

Where/how do you calculate this?

College Hockey News has a "customize" tab and then "modify game results" tab in their Pairwise ratings. You can change any results for any team on the season and it will calculate what the current PWR would be. A "what could have been" calculator if you will.

There's a couple of combinations of changing 3 losses to 3 wins that would have the Badgers 13-10-1 and #6 PWR. A couple of combinations of 2 wins would have them at 12-11-1 and #12 PWR right now.

They are currently #30.
 
Re: Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

On the 1st rounders: Caufield can play in the NHL right now. His total game isn't consistent enough yet or developed enough yet, but there are only a handful of guys in the world that can shoot the puck the way he can, and that's enough to get on the NHL ice. If he stays it's because of his teammates, or out of a desire to mature physically a bit more, but I don't think it will be because he doesn't have a roster spot to start the year.

Turcotte's Dad (Alfie) went up too soon and his NHL career never really got going. I don't think Alex will be in a hurry if there's some question about his game being ready, and right now he doesn't look ready. Another year would be a huge benefit to him long term.

Miller has the ability to go to the show, it just depends on how his season finishes. He could get going and dominate or he could just continue playing how he has been. It's not unusual at all for 1st round D to play 3 or 4 years NCAA, in fact it's unusual for them to play less than that. I think both he and Alex return.

Kalynuk could go pro, and probably should, as I think he has a game that's better suited to pro hockey.

I don't think that any NHL staff is worried at all about leaving their guys here to develop. They are playing the toughest schedule in NCAA and getting premier training. It's a great place for them to be.

Season has been frustrating to no end. I noticed though that if you flip just 3 losses to wins you can get the Badgers to #6 PWR right now. That's kind of crazy.

I’m no expert, but I know what I see. Our two first round forwards are far to inconspicuous for long stretches of games at the college level. Caufield didn’t get a shot last night until well into the 2nd if not the third period, and don’t get me started on his coverage in the d-zone. Sure, they wow you now and again, but I don’t see them elevating the team play. They get physically dominated too often in college. They would get annihilated in the NHL right now. You might be right, but my eyes are showing me otherwise. Way too inconsistent.

As for PWR, flip one or two others and they’d be near the bottom. They are what they are and that is dead last in the conference. No need to remind me that they’re young, we hear it every time one of the staff opens their mouths.
 
Last edited:
Re: Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

I don't believe that in a second. Going from #30 to #6 just by flipping 3 losses to wins?

I've always been considered very good in sales & marketing, but EVEN I couldn't sell that.
 
Re: Wisconsin Hockey 2019-20 Part II: Civil War

I’m no expert, but I know what I see. Our two first round forwards are far to inconspicuous for long stretches of games at the college level. Caufield didn’t get a shot last night until well into the 2nd if not the third period, and don’t get me started on his coverage in the d-zone. Sure, they wow you now and again, but I don’t see them elevating the team play. They get physically dominated too often in college. They would get annihilated in the NHL right now. You might be right, but my eyes are showing me otherwise. Way too inconsistent.

As for PWR, flip 1 or two others and they’d be near the bottom. They are what they are and that is dead last in the conference.

100% correct.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top