Utica isn't going to fall much below E2. If you compare them with Norwich, Norwich wins winning percentage by a good margin and record vs ranked teams by a good margin. Utica wins SOS by a pretty good margin, there is no H2H, and the only common opponent is Neumann. It's a pretty close comparison right now, and it depends on how much the committee weights the factors in comparing the two. With the sample size for COP so small it's hard to see that carrying a lot of weight.
Beyond that, I think Utica is still a lock, but if Norwich wins the ECAC E, I think two more wins over ranked teams will make the SOS comparison closer and move Norwich farther ahead in RNK, and that probably gives them the #1 seed.