Re: Union at St. Cloud (10/16, 10/17) - Never Won vs. Never Been
A BRIEF HISTORY OF UNION HOCKEY
A RED CLOUD PRODUCTION
Part III: Redefining Suck
After missing the playoffs in 2002, the ECAC expanded its playoffs from 10 teams to all 12 teams in a move that was popularly referred to at the time as the “Union rule.” At the same time, they allowed that the top 8 teams in the league would each have a home-ice series during the playoffs. Thanks to a rule change, things were starting to finally look up for Union.
That season, the Dutchmen managed to finish sixth in the ECAC, their second highest finish ever. Under the previous rules, they still would have been on the road for the playoffs, but with the new standard, Union got to host their first ever playoff series. Their opponents? The despised “rivals,” who finished in eleventh after a miserable season. The sun was coming out. It was finally Union’s time to gain the upper hand.
And then the door closed again. RPI swept the series in Schenectady, running their playoff futility streak to 11. The second game of the series was especially heartbreaking for the Dutch. Up 2-1 late in the game, Union went on the power-play looking to ice the game and force Game 3. Instead, Engineers forward Ben Barr scored two short-handed goals on the same penalty (in largely the same fashion, as goaltender Kris Mayotte wandered out of his net to play a loose puck and mishandled it both times), and the Engineers went on to win, 3-2.
During this time period, good coaches came through Schenectady but ended up leaving under similar circumstances as Ned Harkness. Stan Moore took the reins in 1996 and immediately brought the Dutchmen a sixth place finish. He was run out of town in 1998, but he later coached Colgate to an unexpected ECAC regular season championship. Kevin Sneddon then took over and finally dragged Union kicking and screaming out of the doldrums of the league, but left for greener pastures in Vermont after getting the Dutch to their first home playoff series – before the Catamounts decided to move to Hockey East, where he’s taken them to the Frozen Four.
The embarrassment rolled on. Clarkson made it 13 in a row the next year, also in Schenectady, with back-to-back pastings of 8-3 and 5-2. They may have been a little upset at Union.
You see, that season was the advent of NCAA’s Proposition 65, which threatened to take away D-I athletic scholarships for D-III schools that “play up” in Division I, schools which included Clarkson, SLU, and RPI. When it came time for a vote on an amendment to the proposition which would grandfather schools already granting scholarships, Union voted against it, becoming the only school in the nation playing in conferences with affected schools to jealously vote to rescind their right to offer athletic scholarships.
The episode granted an important insight into why it was that Union had put together such a long history of misery. "Let me tell you of my idea of being competitive,” said then-President Roger Hull. “Fielding a team that has a reasonable chance of winning every time it steps on the ice… when [Union] got to 40 percent [winning percentage], I was proud, and when they reached nearly 50 percent a few years ago, I was tremendously proud of them.”
A fitting end result of the proposition, which passed, was to deny Union any hope in the future of changing their minds and offering D-I athletic scholarships as a D-III school.
Next: Demanding Respect, Failing to Receive Any