Re: UNH Wildcats 2015-2016 (Part Two) - Managing Decreasing Expectations
Hello all
There are 18 scholarships and most of the money is allocated to top 6 forwards, top 4 defensemen and top goalies. When you have 28 student athletes and 18 scholarships, most can see that teams like UNH search for diamonds in the rough to fill out their roster. BC, BU, Providence and Notre Dame have academic scholarships (UNH does as well but very limited) and upper middle class players families can afford the difference. You need all types and only elite teams can have more than half the players being NHL draft picks.
We never had that many NHL picks (even when there were 9 rounds) and our academic admissions is tougher than most (BC and Notre Dame have reasonably high admissions standards for athletes as well). We have several non-scholarship athletes playing at UNH. I am proud that we do not pull scholarships for those we recruit. I think it is sleazy to ask for a commitment from a student athlete and then renege on that promise when their projected skills are wanting. If you want to be like BC, BU and Northeastern, that is fine but I would rather take the high road to win.
UNH has committed some very good players with 2 year scholarships through the years (the scholarship is for the last 2 years most of the time) who have been integral parts of our team. We probably have 6 full scholarship athletes 8 three year scholarship athletes and 12 two year scholarship athletes with the rest being non-scholarshp athletes or walk-ons.
I wish we had 6 just like Andrew Poturalski and Trevor Van Riemsdyk. We are not as good as I would like them to be but other than Michigan State and Northeastern series, they have truly come to play and have been in almost every game. I am happier with one goal losses or 2 goals with empty-netter than blowouts. We have the talent at forward and in goal to beat anyone and be competitive with the top teams in the country.
I agree 100% on the recruiting ethics - as a recruiter your job is to identify the players who can make your program a winner. If they don't turn out, that's on you as the recruiter and you need to eat your mistakes. If you're a head coach who turns recruiting over to an assistant and the prospects don't turn out, that's on you as a head coach for neglecting the most important part of your job. Ideally, if you work hard and have an eye for talent, you end up with few prospects who don't live up to expectations and it doesn't hurt to honor your agreement with one or two kids. Kids decommit often these days, but as the adult in the situation coaches need to be held to higher standards. I'm willing to ride out the next couple of years, hopeful that UNH can get its recruiting back on track from here on out. But that's the key, getting back on track ASAP so that its only the next couple of years...
I disagree with your statement that UNH has always had to round out its roster with diamonds in the rough or lesser talents. Nobody made the claim that UNH had to settle for recruits when Brian McCloskey was here. In his final season as an assistant UNH's forward group consisted of the following players:
Darren Haydar (219 points), Sean Collins (173), Colin Hemingway (147), Lanny Gare (142), Preston Callendar (140), Steve Saviano (117), Justin Aikins (103), Jim Abbott (94), Nathan Martz (82), Josh Prudden (73). That's ten forwards who turned out to be top-six NCAA talents. That team also included David Busch who scored 32 points as senior, high-profile misses in Eddie Caron and Travis Banga (who were recruited with the expectation they'd be top-six forwards at some point) and Patrick Foley. That team also had four very good to elite puck-moving defensemen in Garrett Stafford, Tyson Teplitsky, Mick Mounsey and Kevin Truelson, as well as Tim Horst, Robbie Barker and Mike Lubesnick who all developed into top four caliber defensemen.
As recently as Paul Thompson's freshman season, the forward group was:
Bobby Butler (121 points), Matt Fornataro (118), Mike Radja (117), Mike Sislo (116) Paul Thompson (112), Phil Desimone (109), Danny Dries (98 - 49 in two seasons at UNH), Jerry Bag-o-Donuts (97), Peter Leblanc (85), JVR (74 - in two seasons). The team also had a very sound and mobile defense led by Craig Switzer and Brad Flaishans and Kevin Regan and Brian Foster in goal.
It is only a recent development that UNH lacks and can't recruit depth - at both forward and defense - to Durham. At some point, the lead recruiters stopped believing that UNH was a destination and issues with facilities, academics, academic money, weight rooms, score boards and university prestige started popping up. They stopped getting into battles (spare a few) for top prospects, because they didn't think they could compete. Add some critical recruiting mistakes and here we are...
The one thing Mike Souza and Glen Stewart MUST do is honestly believe in UNH. The school has everything it needs to recruit top talent, build a roster with great depth and compete with BC, BU, ND, etc., but if you don't believe it as an assistant, you certainly can't sell it. Small schools all over the country compete with the big time programs - UNH has done it. So I don't want to hear about how it can't be done or how they need to accept their place on the recruiting totem-pole.
Who cares about NHL draft picks. How many of the players I listed above were drafted? Its time to get back to consistently landing top-end NCAA talent and not settling for potential diamonds in the rough...