Re: UNH Wildcats 2015-2016 (Part Two) - Managing Decreasing Expectations
I agree that in the abstract, talent wise they seemingly should be doing better. However from looking at the results, they seem to have a fatal flaw at defense that is exposing goalie issues as well.
So far, I am looking for anything positive for the future but have not seen much, either in terms of on ice coaching or in being attractive to players "the hearts and minds" battle. We lost Foegele mid semester, and lost our best two recruits. One, Ryczek is understandable as he seems close to Borek. The other, Farabe didn't even follow Borek to PC, just left UNH. In the 7 months of the change we have a nice third line recruit and a project defenseman. A lot of impact 98s, 99s and 00 have gone elsewhere. Hardly the sea of change I had hoped for in a transition. Seems a lot like the Arab Spring in Egypt. Let's hope we see some tangible results either on the ice or off so we can get a feel for the future.
So you're not subscribing to a "sunshine & balloons" outlook for the future, eh 'Watcher?
I'll see your objective disappointment balanced with hope, and raise you with impatient ire and annoyance ...
This is a program that's been on a gradual yet steady decline for over a decade now. The last few seasons, it's kind of reached a plateau at or around the .500 level. After last year's .500 run, many of us (myself included) chose to focus on an uncharacteristically strong finish as a sign the program might be turning back upwards, and UNH's soft schedule this season (by unanimous acclaim) seemed tailor-made to help the program make that positive turn, along with several promising young players either already here OR on the way soon.
So we wake up this morning, UNH is literally at THE bottom of the HE standings, in the throes of a 7 game losing streak which looks very likely to hit double figures by next weekend. Ironically, the pattern of this UNH season isn't all that unlike what we've usually seen in the past ... with the team playing its best hockey before the turn of the year, and then falling off a proverbial cliff afterwards. Except in the old days, the "Champions of December" would be at or near the top of the national rankings, instead of struggling to get back to .500. And then the old teams would drift along at a .500 pace after the break, but comfortably qualify for the NCAA's and often enough win the HE regular season title. Nowadays UNH's old membership in the HE "Big Four" is nothing but an old memory. The old teams' "postseason problem" was simply underachieving in the playoffs ... now the "postseason problem" has apparently been *solved* by just skipping the NCAA's altogether, and this season's slippage will probably feature a two-and-out loss in the make-believe, everyone-gets-a-medal super-duper preliminary round of the HE semi-playoffs. Oh joy ...
The more this goes on ... the more upset I'm getting at Coach Umile. IF bomber's description of Umile's hands-off role in the recruiting process is even close to accurate - and based on multiple sources here and elsewhere I have no reason to believe it isn't - how can he even try to justify that he's giving his best effort to turn the program around? If that were me, I'd be embarrassed beyond belief, and the two options would be to either (1) step it up and work harder, OR (2) step aside and let someone else step it up and work harder (smarter?).
I really wanted this to end favorably for Coach Umile on his own terms. But my assumption was that he would save the "pipe slippers and rocking chair on the front porch" stage until after he'd retired. The portrait that has been painted for us in recent weeks/months tells me he's gotten an early start to his retirement, and strongly suggests there are important (even crucial) aspects of the head coach's job he is just not engaged in ... by personal choice. I used to chuckle at 'Watcher's assessment of the motivating factor behind all of this as the so-called "Road to 600". I am not laughing any more ... although fittingly for an accomplished coach who probably initially got where he is by a LOT of hard work, it looks like trying to coast in for a "soft landing" at half speed might only get him halfway to that *magic* number.
I caught a lot of flak on here in some quarters for criticizing the outcome of UNH's captain selection process for this season at the end of last season. I mean, what coach allows his players to put forward a captain who's spent most of his career to that point up in the stands, and one whose next postseason game may be his first? Answer - a coach who isn't nearly as engaged in leading his program as he needs to be IF they are to be successful at the highest levels. NOT a criticism of the captain or his teammates - a HUGE indictment of the HC.
My days of measured criticism and idealistic hopes for "Captain Ahab" to finally conquer the White Whale are officially over and done with.
Coach Umile has certainly earned a lot of goodwill from me for all of the good/great times associated with him while running the program, but if the next two-plus seasons are going to be nothing other than playing out his vanity project while we wait for a transition to his hand picked successor (who BTW hasn't ever been a head coach anywhere to my knowledge), then my reservoir of goodwill has been tapped out. If he wants to replenish it, then I'm afraid he's going to have to do it the old-fashioned way ... he's gonna have to earn it. JMHO.