I'm pretty much on board with the above. But I will add that in discussing the top d-men on both teams, you sound foolish if you don't admit TvR is at least on par with the best BC has to offer (Matheson?). He's improved every year since he came in as an outmatched freshman, and while he's not by any stretch without shortcomings, neither is Matheson. If you had an open camp tryout between the UNH and BC defensemen, I'd guess those two would be the top pairing. Knoedel and Pesce would also certainly make the top six.
But if you look up front at the skilled players, it's hard to imagine UNH's best (Downing/Goumas?) any higher than the second line at BC, while guys like Sorkin (this year), Speelman, Willows, Kelleher and maybe Correale being 3rd/4th line types.
---------------
I don't see BC doing the business this season ... but with them, you never know. There are still a lot of players with deep postseason experience on that roster, and you folks know how I feel about that. On the other side, most of UNH's players have never even so much as played in the HE semis at the Garden yet. That's why it's so critical for UNH to re-estanlish themselves at that level (at least) this season, or else next season's team then has virtually zero (0) HE Semis pedigree, and only a few early-round NCAA games to serve as their foundation for postseason experience going forward. You can't underestimate the importance of playing in winner-take-all games.
Once upon a time, these two programs were quite similar, trying hard to break through nationally and just coming up short on multiple occasions. BC finally did break through, and a few seasons later they took it to a whole different level entirely, and have carried that to the present day. UNH never quite got there, and has been gradually slipping back for the better part of the last decade. God knows, I used to be on the front line in those fabulous BC v. UNH debates, when it actually WAS a valid debate. But things have changed, and only the most rabid UNH partisan (e.cat, I'm glad it's you and not me, man

) would deny that this indeed is the new reality. I wish it weren't the case ... but it is. And unless/until BC drops from the top tier consistently for more than a few years, it's unlikely to change.
UNH used to get some of the players that UML and PC are now getting. They don't anymore (but take solace in the fact that UMaine doesn't get them anymore either). BU used to split up their talent pool for the most part with BC, but now that has also tilted in BC's favor. But at least BU can point to a National title in the conscious lifetimes of their recruits for the next decade or so. UMaine's two Nationals now mean virtually zippo to recruits, but at least they have those trophies to warm the hearts of their long-time fans and alums during those cold Downeast wintahs. UNH's pinnacle was winning two HE Tourney trophies back-to-back 10+ years ago now, and coming close in two National Finals at around the same time. Unless you are a recruit who had a precocious interest in college hockey when you were 5-6-7 years old tops, none of that is likely going to mean anything to you.
Then again, maybe that spiffy new cutting-edge logo will turn the tide.

Whatever gets you through the day at Complacency U.