Chuck Murray
WIS & Effingwoods Hockey Almanac
Hey Chuck just wondering if you watched Unrivaled and if so what your thoughts were.
I found it interesting and almost wish I had ESPN+ to watch the expanded edition.
Yeah, Felgie - I did catch it, some of it was fantastic, but in the end I was hoping for more (hence the expanded edition on ESPN+ I'm guessing?). It seemed to end somewhat prematurely, as the final bookend on the rivalry is seen by most on my side of the aisle as the Wings waxing Roy and the Avs 7-0 in Game 7 of the '02 Western Conference Finals. Video is attached to show what was arguably the greatest collection of talent ever seen in the NHL, a year or two before the strike that brought the salary cap (and more parity) into the NHL.
When I say "bookend" ... as the "Unrivaled" E:60 showed, the start of the rivalry was arguably the night the Wings waxed the Canadiens 11-1 in the old Forum in late 1995, when then Montreal goalie Patrick Roy was chased from the game early but left in way too late, leading to the fracturing of his shaky relationship with former teammate/then head coach Mario Tremblay, when Roy literally leaned over to the Habs' GM to demand a trade mid-game after he was pulled. We had rented out the old Children's Museum of Portsmouth (now in Dover, as I understand) for our eldest's 6 year old birthday party that same night, and when we got home afterwards, the Wings were laying the wood to Roy/Habs like never before (or since). Great night!!!
Anyway, that triggered the trade of Roy to the Avs, and then the '96 Western Finals and the Lemieux hit on Draper did the rest. But Roy getting lit up by the Wings started AND ended the rivalry.
The Lemieux/McCarty detente feels more than a little contrived to me though, Felgie. McCarty was an underrated big game performer - his '97 Cup clincher vs. Philly was Exhibit A of several other timely goals in his career - but he seems (to me) to be a little too willing to cash in on every last opportunity to remind folks he was a 4 time Cup winner in Detroit. Kind of a knock-off version of Bob Probert, but Probie misbehaved once too often, got himself traded before the Cups started coming, and McCarty always knew where his bread was buttered. Even now, with diehard DRW fans, there is reverence for a flawed Probert (RIP) who won nothing, and some level of scorn for McCarty, who won lots. Probably down to style points TBH.
But all in all, "Unrivaled" shows a great slice of the greatest extended pro rivalry of my lifetime.