You can't expect a team overnight to go from 0-7-3 to being an NCAA team. That's not how it works. There's no 5 minute movie montage to go from worst to first. You just get better, year on year. Maine is much better than last year, both via the eye test and via results on the ice.
People seem to expect the level of recruits to be what they were in the 1990's. That is delusional. Maine has institutional disadvantages when recruiting against the BC's, BU's, Big Ten schools, North Dakota, Denver, etc. that didn't exist back then. If Maine hockey can be, on average, about a .500 program, that's probably better than the University of Maine should have, all things being equal. We don't have the facilities, fanbase or money to be much more than that. Some years, do a little better, make the NCAAs. Some years, a little worse, travel in the first round of the HEA playoffs. Expecting the Frozen Four every year is just setting yourself up for perennial disappointment.
And, Monty coming to coach here was always nuts. He's at Denver where he can name his budget, an expensive private school in a popular city that puts all their eggs in the hockey basket. We are a poor, rural, public school in a declining state. No chance Maine could match Denver's salary, facilities or recruiting budget.
I'm not saying Red is a great coach who gets the most out of his players- I'm not in the locker room so I don't know. But he isn't a failure if he gets this to a .500 program.