What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

Re: Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

Happy Ides of April, Everyone!

If there are others like me slogging to transpose numbers from a line on one schedule to a line on another schedule so I can finish a third schedule......here are some encouraging words from Judge Learned Hand, one of the most notable non-Supreme Court justice in US history.


Any one may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which will best pay the Treasury; there is not even a patriotic duty to increase one's taxes.
from Helvering v. Gregory, 69 F.2d 809, 810-11 (2d Cir. 1934).




Best of luck to all. and as my spouse reminds me, all in all it's generally better to be in a position where you are paying taxes, than the alternative.
 
Re: Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

Y'alls have my sympathy.

I filed back in January, because for the first time in years I had a refund waiting for me.

The previous few years, though, I waited until the last possible day before making that last payment. I knew that was the right way, economically. Why overpay and let the government earn interest? Psychologically, though, it was a different story. April 15 sucked. :)
 
Re: Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

OMG. High school Latin *wasn't* complete waste of my time, 'cause now I get to correct someone on a message board! The ides of April is on April 13, not 15th. File that away - you, too, might have a use for it 23 years after you learned it.... :)

Oh, great, so the Ides of April this year were Friday the 13th.

What an interesting morning, LOL....by Fed return including 6251 (AMT) was just under an hour, while NYState non-resident return was 1 hr 45 minutes....now for other states....

(I'm glad I'm not a professional entertainer or pro athlete, though if I were I'd have an accountant or two on staff!). Every state in which you have earned income requires a separate state income tax return....which means if you earn a living by commuting to another state or if you work for a consulting firm and work several weeks in several states, or if you move from one state to another during a year, or [see footnote C on worksheet III on p22 unless you qualify for these exceptions, so that you reference footnote D on worksheet IV on p24 instead....]

My sympathies actually go out to the people who work for IRS or state revenue dept because they did not write the dopey laws they merely have to figure out how to write the forms and instructions to implement the actual legislation passed by the legislators.

I think we should pass US and State Constitutional amendments that require ALL legislators to do their own taxes; they are not allowed to hire accountants! That might teach them to pass laws in language ordinary people can understand and follow!
 
Re: Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

Y'alls have my sympathy.

I filed back in January, because for the first time in years I had a refund waiting for me.

The previous few years, though, I waited until the last possible day before making that last payment. I knew that was the right way, economically. Why overpay and let the government earn interest? Psychologically, though, it was a different story. April 15 sucked. :)

Even if I get a refund, I typically have to wait until at least March to file, because the gosh darn oil royalty companies don't publish their tax booklets until then. I've come to keeping my own tabs for dividends, capital gains, and buy/sell, because gosh knows my broker can't get the 1099-DIV and 1099-B correct to save their lives.
 
Re: Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

NY State is really sneaky compared to most other states when it comes to non-resident income tax.

Most other states just tax you on non-resident income at their state income tax rates. Simple, straightforward, fair. If it is your state of residency, you get a credit equal to the lesser of tax paid elsewhere or what you would have paid in tax were that income earned in your state. Again, simple, straightfoward, fair.

For NY state, you first put down your entire taxable income from all states. Then you figure out your NY tax on that entire income. Then you pro-rate that tax by the amount of income earned in NY.

Because NY has graduated rates, you are paying tax in a higher bracket than if you only paid tax on the income earned in that state, because the rest of your income from other states, plus your spouse's income, are all added. Also, NY does not have a graduated tax structure, once you move into a higher bracket, you pay tax at that rate from dollar $0. So it's a double whammy for non-resident income earned in NY state.

Fortunately for me, when we first moved into our new home, way back in the last millenia, we built a space 100% dedicated to work. Our office is separate from the home, so that I can walk out one door, walk 8 feet, walk in another door, and be done with my commute on those days I'm not traveling elsewhere, yet still be in an office (and technically not "working from home") for tax purposes.
 
Re: Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

Paying too little. Paying too much will suck today, but paying too little will suck for years in the future (when you will have to pay too much to cover the interest on the giant pile of debt).
Yeah, paying too little. The IRS made a mistake on the first tax return I ever filed and even though I proved it and they withdrew their claim I swear my SSN is flagged forever.

As the comic said, "if you ever feel lonely, stop paying your taxes."
 
Re: Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

So, today, half of us have Benjamin Dover as our alter ego....

A little historical perspective:
The Alternative Minimum Tax was imposed in 1969 because 115 households investing in municipal bonds reportedly paid little or no federal income tax. This tax ... now affects four million households. [In] 2013, it is set to hit 27 million more .... In 40 years, a tax on 115 households will have grown to ... 31 million.

The personal income tax, brought courtesy of the 16th Amendment, ... began in 1913 with a top rate of 7% and hit only those with a taxable income of $500,000 or more. (According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics inflation calculator, that would be $11.5 million now.) Today, roughly half of American families pay the personal income tax.

Maine imposed an income tax in 1969, and the tax that once only hit folks earning more than $308,000 in today's dollars now hits Mainers with a rate of 8.5% and kicks in at $19,950.

Over 20 years ago, the State of Connecticut introduced a "temporary" income tax to cover a "short-term" budget shortfall. After raising the rate multiple times, the state income tax now affects nearly everyone with income and is the primary source of state revenue. In the same time period, according to a UConn study published last year, there has been no net job growth in CT and the public sector has expanded in size (while they did not say it, if you "do the math" there must have been a loss of private sector jobs during that time period). The tax hits single filers with income over $13,000 and married filing jointly at $24,000.
 
Last edited:
Re: Tax Season 2012: Work No Longer Pays

The tax burden is actually historically low.

a large majority of American households — about two out of three — pays less than 15 percent of income to the federal government, through either income taxes or payroll taxes

Right now you are in clover on taxation if you are:

(1) Poor. (I don't think this is a consolation.)

(2) Rich. (Lower rates and more exemptions and deductions.)

(3) Super rich. (Top marginal rate half of what it was for much of the 20th century).


The Middle Class has a relatively low tax burden up front but we pay for it by subsidizing the wealthy's tax breaks and also because we're the ones who will be on the hook to pay for all the stuff that's been falling to pieces since the Reaganites declared Jesus wanted the rich to have a tax holiday.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top