What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

Rule change proposals 2020: "Really?"

Let's be honest, the end of game handshake after a wwcha game and the one after a Stanley Cup series are not even on the same planet in terms of real meaning. The Stanley Cup ones are truly heartfelt, players looking each other in the eye, saying a few kind words, a pat on the back or shoulder, it's awesome.
I agree on the awesomeness of the Stanley Cup handshakes. It's likely true that the rarity of them enhances the tradition. And for multiple reasons, I wouldn't recommend handshakes after individual games in a pro playoff series, until the series is complete.

Watching the wwcha players spin through the handshake their minds are anywhere but on the task, other than some of the C's who you can tell at least level on eye on each other. It's really a waste of time.
With all due respect, I think you need to watch the WWCHA handshakes with a more discerning eye. To me, there are almost always are interesting moments. Handshakes between players who competed with or against each other in high school. Or on national teams. Players that went head-to-head hard during the game, then express respect for each other afterwords. And so on.

And let's talk about meaning. To me, one thing the handshake line signifies is that what happens on the ice, stays on the ice. It was a good battle; no hard feelings. Of course that isn't always true, but "leave it on the ice" is a good ideal to strive for. What message are you sending by refusing to shake hands?

All that said, I do thank you for the reply. I asked where the opposition was coming from, and you provided at least part of the answer.

The "waste of time" theory didn't occur to me. Maybe the majority agrees with you, maybe not. But either way, at least it's a rational motivation.
 
With all due respect, I think you need to watch the WWCHA handshakes with a more discerning eye. To me, there are almost always are interesting moments. Handshakes between players who competed with or against each other in high school. Or on national teams. Players that went head-to-head hard during the game, then express respect for each other afterwords. And so on.

I definitely pay close attention to them, hence my opinion. We agree that there are interesting moments, but for the most part they remind me of the Clark Griswald running into his boss and his entourage in the hallway in Christmas Vacation.
 
I assumed that the motivation for backing off on requiring handshakes now was Covid-19 related. In terms of the long term, I think that a good compromise might be to only shake hands at the conclusion of a series. For example, why shake hands after Game 1 of a best-of-three playoff series? Shaking on the eve of a rematch makes it seem more perfunctory to me.
 
I definitely pay close attention to them, hence my opinion. We agree that there are interesting moments, but for the most part they remind me of the Clark Griswald running into his boss and his entourage in the hallway in Christmas Vacation.
I'm really not trying to be difficult, but I'm just baffled by your opinion. We're watching the same thing, but experiencing it completely differently. Guess you're just a brother from a different planet.;)

I will say this. If the majority agrees with you, then we should just drop the handshakes. If that is the case, I'd get over it very quickly. Handshakes are a tradition I've always liked, but they aren't essential to the game.
 
I assumed that the motivation for backing off on requiring handshakes now was Covid-19 related.
That's fine; but was there anything in the announcement that indicated this? And if reducing the spread of the virus is the true motivation, why not have a uniform policy and be done with it? What are the "local differences" that make shaking hands safe at some rinks, but not others?

If the powers-that-be want to suspend all handshake lines until there's a vaccine, I'll get on board with that one -- no qualms or hesitation.

In terms of the long term, I think that a good compromise might be to only shake hands at the conclusion of a series. For example, why shake hands after Game 1 of a best-of-three playoff series? Shaking on the eve of a rematch makes it seem more perfunctory to me.
I'd be fine with this as well. If you conceptualize the end of Game 1 as kind of a half-time, it does make sense. No one shakes hands at halftime of a Football or Soccer game.
 
I'm really not trying to be difficult, but I'm just baffled by your opinion. We're watching the same thing, but experiencing it completely differently. Guess you're just a brother from a different planet.;)

It's very interesting that I see Clark Griswald and you see Hallmark movie ending LOL. It's just fun to chat about totally non-political/covid stuff as insanity and a complete loss of logic rages around us. Did you see Muzzy stack up a bunch of recruits over the last week or so?
 
It's very interesting that I see Clark Griswald and you see Hallmark movie ending LOL. It's just fun to chat about totally non-political/covid stuff as insanity and a complete loss of logic rages around us.
Definitely. When I first commented on the handshake change, the pandemic was nowhere in my thinking. My thoughts were just about hockey in normal times. ARM appropriately added the pandemic to the conversation, bringing us back to reality. Of course consideration of that factor was a must. But it was nice to escape from it for a couple of posts.

One more thought on the different perceptions. Not that I do any real advance planning. But usually when I watch the handshake line, I'm on the lookout for 2-3 potentially interesting pairings. Maybe I tune out all of the players who just zip through the line.

Zip Lining & Hockey shouldn't mix. Who knew?:D

Did you see Muzzy stack up a bunch of recruits over the last week or so?
Actually, from my desk chair, our big news is that Zoe Hickel (UMD Alum) has joined the coaching staff:

https://ohiostatebuckeyes.com/zoe-hi...oaching-staff/

I haven't gotten the memo yet on new verbal commitments. Do you have a link?
 
(Unconfirmed but fairly certain) Milica McMillen.
The site shows Hickel and West as the assistants. I take it this means that Wisniewski's volunteer stint is over (or maybe he plans to help out when he can, as opposed to a more formal role)?
 
Ah, just another rite of summer....sunburn, buttery salty sweetcorn, lightening bugs and Muzzy switching assistants. LOL.
It was pointed out to me that Milica was not present on the OSU bench prior to last season's end. I have no other information on that, but was the reason for the promptness of my previous reply.
Getting back on topic of rule changes, this is not hockey specific, but it's an interesting new "ruling"...

https://www.uscho.com/2020/07/30/nca...tive-purposes/
 
It was pointed out to me that Milica was not present on the OSU bench prior to last season's end. I have no other information on that, but was the reason for the promptness of my previous reply.

Now that you say that, the volunteer dude was on the bench for the WI series. I distinctly recall that I was impressed with his wardrobe and I didn't have any issues looking over him like Milica because he isn't 8 feet tall.
 
Back
Top