I will take these one at a time:
1. Read carefully. There have been more than one poster in this thread questioning whether or not Appert is recruiting any talent, so there are people questioning his recruiting abilities.
2. They probably left because someone gave them a wonderful opportunity to go pro that may not ever show up again for them. It sucks but that is the reality. What would you do in their shoes? (skates?)
3. Not necessarily true, see Chris Kreider/Carl Hagelin also on the New York Rangers. That's a wide assumption to make, for all we know they could stick Haggerty on the third or fourth line and he could be putting the puck in the net left and right.
As for the goaltending thing, not even remotely true. As evidenced by the fact that, you know, we were scoring in leaps and bounds this year, maybe the real trick is that the ECAC is stacked with good goal tending and defensive corps as a league? Hence the low-scoring games our league is infamous for?
I'm wondering where you are getting your analyses from. Sometimes I believe you're being contrarian just for the sake of arguing.